Peer Revenue Equity in science

Papers

Fresh from arXiv, typeset properly. Highlighted words trade on the market.

Statistics

stat Watch Statistics (sign in to use)

Tuesday 14 July

Statistical Methodology

Symbolic Weak-form Recovery of 2-D Stochastic Generators

Recovering two-dimensional Ito generators from trajectory data is difficult because drift increments have low signal-to-noise, bivariate weak designs can be ill-conditioned, and unconstrained tensor estimates need not be positive semidefinite. We study WG-SINDy estimator combining covariance-shaped spatial kernels, a ridge-stabilized local-polynomial projection, adaptive-LASSO/STLSQ selection, one in-sample per-component feasible diagonal GLS pass, and a PSD projection–Cholesky read-out with mild isotropic shrinkage. The released estimator uses a data-dependent full-cloud smoother and one in-sample per-component feasible diagonal GLS pass; accordingly, we do not claim exact finite-sample martingale cancellation or a feasible-GLS efficiency theorem for the reported implementation. We evaluate the estimator on 29 synthetic two-dimensional systems: 19 meet their declared per-system recovery contracts, eight are retained as named limits, and two remain scoped reviews. Across the 19 PASS rows, the median central-grid drift metric is 0.204 and the median tensor error is 0.0397. Among the six systems with a finite, non-degenerate off-diagonal target, the median $a_{12}$ cosine is 0.997. Positive-semidefinite validity is imposed by construction. These results are synthetic, in-sample sampled-region diagnostics and do not establish universal or real-data recovery.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics) · Cross-listed from cs.LG

Gauge-Fixing the Forward-Forward Objective: A Whitened Goodness Derived from a Likelihood-Ratio Account

The Forward-Forward algorithm trains each layer locally, so that a scalar goodness - the sum of squared activations - is high on real inputs and low on contrastive ones. Under an explicit generative model this goodness is the sufficient statistic of a likelihood-ratio test, and the pairwise form of the objective admits a gauge: a layer can lower its loss by inflating the scale of its weights rather than by separating the two populations. The analysis prescribes the repair - a whitened, scale-invariant goodness trained online within each layer - which we evaluate as a training procedure. Across three corpora, three depths and a fourfold range of layer width (13 seeds per cell), it raises linear-probe accuracy over the standard pairwise objective in every measured cell - by 4 to 7 points on eight of nine corpus-depth combinations - and closes 16-61% of the gap to end-to-end backpropagation. A control isolates the mechanism: Hinton's fixed-threshold loss also bounds the runaway, to a factor of 1.4 against 133, yet tracks the unmodified baseline - invariance to the gauge, not a bound on it, is what pays. Against the strongest published alternative - a sparse, top-k goodness - the derived objective is statistically indistinguishable on two corpora of three, yet only it removes the runaway: sparsity and gauge-invariance are independent axes, and the published variant recovers accuracy while leaving the pathology in place. We state the boundaries we measured, and every prediction was recorded before its experiment with the refutations reported.
Read the full abstract

Statistical Methodology

Does a Developed Comorbidity Index Really Add Value? A Selection-Aware Bootstrap for Post-Selection Concordance

Disease-specific comorbidity indices are routinely developed by building several candidate constructions and reporting the best-scoring one, then claiming it adds discriminative value over a fixed off-the-shelf comparator such as the Charlson or Elixhauser score. We show that the optimism correction in standard use does not make that claim valid. Because it corrects the selected model as if it were the only one ever fit, it omits the winner's-curse term from choosing the best of several candidates; so its confidence interval for the incremental concordance is not merely optimistic in small samples but structurally miscalibrated, and does not shrink as the sample grows. At a true null it inflates false claims of added value above the nominal level, increasingly so as more candidates are screened. We introduce a drop-in selection-aware bootstrap that re-runs the best-of-several selection inside each resample with the comparator held fixed, removing the structural bias. In a fully-known-truth simulation, 95% coverage under the standard correction falls from 0.94 with one candidate to 0.70 with a hundred, while the selection-aware interval holds near nominal; its coverage matches a calibrated cross-validation interval, and at a matched error rate it is at least as powerful. The results hold under Uno's concordance, and a semi-synthetic experiment on real survey data confirms when the correction matters. In practice, if several constructions were tried, report a selection-aware interval, most needed with many similar-quality candidates and few events per candidate. The scope is discrimination only; software and results reproduce every finding.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics) · Cross-listed from cs.LG

Fisher Rank Inflation: A Spectral Signature of Memorization under Label Noise

Deep networks trained with label noise often learn clean structure before memorizing corrupted labels. We show that this transition leaves a spectral signature in the centered scatter of per-example last-layer gradients. Its effective rank transiently expands during memorization and contracts after corrupted labels are fit. We call this phenomenon Fisher Rank Inflation. Corrupted labels increase effective rank by injecting spectral mass into low-energy or previously unused eigendirections, increasing the entropy of the gradient spectrum. We derive a first-order leave-one-out attribution formula, identify conditions under which corrupted examples contribute more strongly than clean examples, and explain why attribution signals weaken once the normalized Fisher-gradient spectrum stabilizes. We test these predictions on CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100, and CIFAR-10N using SmallCNN, ResNet18, and Vision Transformers. Across settings, Fisher effective rank exhibits a consistent inflation–collapse trajectory aligned with memorization. At peak-rank checkpoints, corrupted examples are enriched among the highest rank-contributing samples, with top-100 noisy fractions from \(69.2\%\) to \(96.2\%\) across five-seed synthetic-corruption experiments and \(94.4\%\pm1.9\%\) on CIFAR-10N. First-order spectral attribution closely matches exact leave-one-out contributions in convolutional models and remains enriched in the Vision Transformer. Peak effective rank increases monotonically with corruption severity, from \(28.88\pm1.95\) under clean training to \(97.09\pm1.78\) at \(60\%\) corruption. In several settings, the retrospectively identified onset of rank inflation precedes observable test degradation. These results establish Fisher Rank Inflation as a spectral signature connecting corrupted-example enrichment, corruption severity, and the transition from structure learning to memorization.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics) · Cross-listed from cs.LG

PolarBM: Complex-valued Boltzmann Machine for Modeling Audio Signals in Polar and Log-polar Coordinates

Although vast amounts of data, such as audio signal spectra, are naturally represented using complex numbers, conventional machine learning methods often simplify complex-domain problems by employing frameworks designed for real-valued variables. While this simplification offers computational benefits, it discards structural information regarding the inherent relationship between amplitude and phase. In this paper, we propose a novel Boltzmann machine (BM), named PolarBM, capable of naturally handling complex-valued variables in the polar coordinate (i.e., an amplitude-phase representation). PolarBM defines a probability density function for complex variables in which the phase explicitly depends on the amplitude, thereby capturing the physically important relationships of complex-valued signals. Furthermore, to process audio signals in accordance with human auditory perception, we propose LogPolarBM, which models amplitude on a logarithmic scale. This extension yields a flexible conditional probability density function, a power-weighted noncentral complex Gaussian (PW-NCCG) distribution, whose marginal amplitude distribution encompasses the Rice, Nakagami, and noncentral chi distributions as special cases. For practical applications, we also introduce the restricted variants of these proposed models: PolarRBM and LogPolarRBM. Experimental results demonstrate that by explicitly modeling the dependency between amplitude and phase, the proposed RBMs achieve superior modeling accuracy compared to conventional models, including deep neural networks. Although our experiments focus on audio signals, the utility of the proposed BMs is not limited to audio applications; their potential extends widely across various fields of science and engineering that involve complex-valued data, such as wireless communications and quantum mechanics.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics) · Cross-listed from q-fin.ST

Statistical Properties and Power Analysis of Divergence Measures for Credit Risk Model Monitoring

Divergence measures are essential tools for detecting distributional shifts in model monitoring, particularly crucial given the volatility of financial data. While the Population Stability Index is the most widely used measure, Jensen-Shannon Divergence and Kullback-Leibler Divergence offer distinct advantages. Jensen-Shannon Divergence handles mixture models, addresses zero-binning problems, and is symmetric, while Kullback-Leibler Divergence excels in Bayesian model comparison. This study extends the work of Yurdakul and Naranjo (2020) with two primary contributions. First, we derive the statistical properties and chi-square benchmark values for Jensen-Shannon Divergence and Kullback-Leibler Divergence. Second, we demonstrate their applicability by detecting distributional changes in credit default probabilities from Merton, Merton with jump, and stochastic volatility with jump models. Our results establish that Jensen-Shannon Divergence and Kullback-Leibler Divergence follow chi-square distributions and reveal important practical trade-offs. Jensen-Shannon Divergence exhibits superior Type I error control, maintaining rejection rates closest to 5%, thereby minimizing false positives. However, this conservatism reduces statistical power at small samples (27% versus 32% for Population Stability Index and Kullback-Leibler Divergence at n = m = 200), requiring larger samples for reliable detection. This trade-off enables practitioners to select measures based on whether minimizing false alarms or maximizing detection sensitivity is the priority.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics)

Thompson Sampling Is 2-Competitive for Mistakes

We consider Bayesian bandit models and prove that Thompson sampling makes at most twice the expected number of mistakes (selections of a suboptimal arm) as any other policy. Our analysis applies as long as the latent arm processes are independent and each arm evolves only when played. For stochastic bandits with best arm defined via mean reward, this confirms a conjecture of Guha and Munagala from 2014, where the factor $2$ is already best possible. The result holds under any nonincreasing sequence of round weights, including fixed horizon and geometric discounting.
Read the full abstract

Statistical Methodology

Hierarchical Bayesian inversion using the Karhunen-Loève expansion with analytical eigenpairs of the squared exponential kernel

Hierarchical Bayesian inversion with Gaussian random field priors addresses uncertainty in covariance hyperparameters, such as the standard deviation and correlation length. When a Gaussian random field is represented by the Karhunen-Loève (KL) expansion, the basis functions depend on these hyperparameters through an integral eigenvalue problem (IEVP) associated with the covariance kernel. Consequently, the IEVP must be solved repeatedly whenever the hyperparameters are updated, leading to significant computational cost in hierarchical inference. In this paper, we focus on the squared exponential kernel and construct the KL expansion using the analytical solution to a Gaussian-weighted IEVP. This analytical KL expansion offers a computationally efficient alternative to the conventional KL expansion by eliminating the repeated numerical solutions of the IEVP during hyperparameter updates. While the analytical KL expansion is applicable to arbitrary domains and dimensions, it does not have the same mean-square optimality as the conventional KL expansion. To address this limitation, we employ an optimization-based approach that selects the standard deviation of the Gaussian weight function in the IEVP to effectively reduce the truncation error of the KL expansion. Numerical experiments in one- and two-dimensional settings show that this selection strategy provides sufficient accuracy for practical applications. Furthermore, the analytical KL expansion admits closed-form differentiation, enabling efficient posterior sampling via HMC. The proposed framework is applied to Bayesian inversion for a steady Darcy flow model, where the hydraulic conductivity field is successfully estimated using weakly informative hyperpriors.
Read the full abstract

Statistical Methodology

Nonparametric Multi Change Point Detection for Markov Chains via Adaptive Clustering

Offline change point detection tries to detect time points of distribution change in a given data sequence; and is now routinely used in signal processing, speech processing, climatology etc. Despite this broad applicability across economics, computer science, and planetary sciences, rigorous, nonparametric techniques for change point detection with non-independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) datasets has remained elusive. This paper establishes such guarantees by proposing a non-parametric clustering algorithm which can accurately obtain the change points from a given Markovian dataset of length $n$. It does so by bridging together two different components of mathematical statistics; Rademacher complexities of Markov chains, and adaptive clustering via penalisation. Our first result uses recent advances in Rademacher complexities of regenerating Markov chains to derive a Dvoretzky Kiefer Wolfowitz (DKW) type inequality for the empirical distribution of the Markov chain. We then use this to show that an adaptive clustering algorithm recovers the correct change points for a Markovian sequence. We establish the tightness of our rates by showing that they essentially coincide with the best known rates for i.i.d. data. We end the paper by discussing the computational considerations of the problem.
Read the full abstract

Statistical Methodology · Cross-listed from econ.GN

Forecasting Inflation with Microdata: An Adaptive Machine Learning Approach

Does microeconomic heterogeneity help to forecast aggregate inflation in a non-stationary environment? We develop a scan test for whether one forecast outperforms another, over an interval with unknown starting point and duration. To exploit any occasional forecasting power that the scan test detects, we design an adaptive machine learning pipeline. We encode the distribution of price changes into a high-dimensional vector, which we combine with a gradient boosted trees algorithm. We then combine this micro forecast with other benchmark forecasts, using an adaptive algorithm that makes use of the micro forecast only when it performs well. We apply the pipeline to UK microdata, with four main results. First, the micro forecast outperforms a univariate benchmark, but only in the volatile period after 2020. Second, the scan test detects periods of micro outperformance, so the micro forecast enters the combined forecast. Third, the combined forecast performs comparably to the univariate benchmark before 2020 and better at every horizon after 2020. Fourth, the value of microdata for the combined forecast materializes after 2020. We conclude that microdata are valuable for forecasting aggregate inflation, but only after large shocks.
Read the full abstract

All authors Catherine Chen, Chen Gao, Jonathon Hazell, Lihua Lei, Chen Lian

Machine Learning (Statistics) · Cross-listed from cs.LG

Cluster-Weighted EDMD

Extended Dynamic Mode Decomposition (EDMD) approximates Koopman operators from data, but a single global operator is inefficient when different state-space regions exhibit distinct local dynamics. We introduce Cluster-Weighted EDMD (CW-EDMD), which jointly learns a soft phase-space partition and a per-cluster EDMD operator. Its Expectation-Maximization (EM) objective assigns each transition based on both geometric proximity and prediction residuals, so clusters specialize where local Koopman models are accurate rather than where the data are dense. On Lorenz, damped pendulum, and Duffing systems, across 36 configurations and 10 seeds, CW-EDMD improves matched-degree EDMD in one-step and 5s-rollout prediction. Across 288 paired comparisons, there are significant error reductions in 258 cases, increases in 4, and no differences in 26. Median one-step error reductions are 57x, 2.7x, and 12x on pendulum, Duffing, and Lorenz, respectively.
Read the full abstract

All authors Lorenzo Tomaz, Judd Rosenblatt, Flavio Kicis, Thomas B. Jones, Diogo Schwerz de Lucena

Monday 13 July

Machine Learning (Statistics)

Disentangling Forced and Internal Climate Variability in Single Realizations using Dynamic Mode Decomposition with Control

We show that a single climate realization can be decomposed into forced and internal components by treating external forcing as a dynamical driver within a linear stochastic system, an idea grounded in pullback attractor theory. In doing so, we address a central methodological challenge in climate science with direct implications for climate projection and the detection and attribution of the forced response, disentangling the forced climate response from internal variability in a single observed record. Statistical methods range from approaches trained on large ensembles to techniques operating on single realizations. The latter often rely on linear frameworks such as linear inverse models (LIMs) and linear regression. LIMs ignore forcing predictors, whereas linear regression omits climate system dynamics. Here we introduce PullbackDMDc, a method grounded in non-autonomous dynamical systems theory and dynamic mode decomposition with control (DMDc), incorporating pullback attractor estimation to decompose a single climate realization into spatial modes and their associated forced and internal components, yielding a physically interpretable picture of the underlying dynamics. We illustrate the utility of PullbackDMDc for Earth System Model (ESM) evaluation by applying it to near-surface air temperature and sea-level pressure from reanalysis and four ESM large ensembles. PullbackDMDc estimates the forced response with skill matching or exceeding established baselines and identifies optimal forcing predictors against model-based ground truth. Its internal variability components reveal that ESMs qualitatively capture interannual and decadal modes while exhibiting systematic differences relative to each other and to observations. Skillful forced response estimation and a novel decomposition position PullbackDMDc as a practical tool for single-realization climate analysis and ESM evaluation.
Read the full abstract

Statistics Theory

The Benjamini–Hochberg Procedure Can Fail to Control the FDR for Correlated Two-Sided Gaussian Tests

We show that the Benjamini–Hochberg procedure can fail to control the false discovery rate (FDR) at its nominal level for correlated two-sided Gaussian $p$-values. We construct a factor model for which, at level $\alpha=0.01$, a rigorous interval-arithmetic certificate proves $FDR>0.0104$ for all sufficiently large numbers of hypotheses. This disproves a conjecture widely believed to be true for twenty years. Monte Carlo experiments are consistent with the theoretical result. The proof was obtained by GPT-5.6 Pro and carefully checked by the author.
Read the full abstract

Statistical Methodology

Fitting Generalized Linear Mixed-Effects Models using lme4

The lme4 R package can be used to fit generalized linear mixed models (GLMMs), which extend the class of linear mixed models (LMMs). The two main extensions provided by GLMMs are (1) allowing for the conditional distribution of the response given the random effects to be non-Gaussian (e.g. binomial, Poisson) and (2) allowing the conditional mean to be a nonlinear function of a linear combination of the fixed and random effect coefficients, via an inverse link function. The conditional mode of the random effects given the observed data, the variance-covariance matrix of the random effects, and the fixed effect parameters are determined using penalized iteratively reweighted least squares. We compute an approximation of the integral over the distributions of the conditional modes to compute the maximum likelihood estimate for a given set of parameters (by default we use the Laplace approximation or, alternatively, the more computationally expensive adaptive Gauss-Hermite quadrature). The package provides all the standard features available for GLMs in base R, including the standard set of accessor functions as well as the possibility of user-specified distributions (within the exponential dispersion family) and link functions.
Read the full abstract

All authors Anna Ly, Rune Haubo Bojesen Christensen, Douglas Bates, Martin Maechler, Benjamin M. Bolker

Machine Learning (Statistics)

Falsifying Causal Graphs With Outlier Events

True causal relationships are rarely known, and inferring causal graphs from data is hard. A fundamental challenge is how to assess whether a given causal graph is good in the absence of a ground truth. We propose falsifying candidate causal graphs based on whether they can explain the propagation of an outlier event. Our approach leverages a key principle: weak outliers rarely cause strong ones. While this principle has previously been used in root cause analysis to identify root causes without prior knowledge of the graph, we turn it on its head and use it to falsify candidate causal graphs whose implied outlier propagation is inconsistent with the data. To this end, we present the first statistical tests for the hypothesis that a candidate graph is the true causal graph, and show they have false positive control, power guarantees against incorrect causal graphs, and can operate with a single outlier sample.
Read the full abstract

Statistics Theory

Causal Graphs, Markov Properties and Do-calculus for Stochastic Differential Equations

Stochastic differential equations (SDEs) are widely used to model continuous-time dynamical systems, but graphical causal models for them are not yet well-understood. We consider systems of causal SDEs that are equipped with an explicit causal semantics. We pose solvability conditions for systems of causal SDEs such that they have well-defined observational and interventional distributions - even after marginalisation - and provide a general class of Lipschitz semimartingale SDEs that satisfies these conditions. As core results we establish the $\sigma$-separation Markov property and the do-calculus in terms of the system's causal graph for probabilistic independence and interventions on the level of sample paths. For a class of additive-noise SDEs we prove a stronger $d$-separation Markov property, even if the system is cyclic. As a corollary of the do-calculus, we obtain an explicit causal interpretation of the graph: that the absence of a directed path implies the absence of a causal effect. We further introduce time-split systems, which consider the causal relations between the processes when evaluated on disjoint intervals or time-points, and use them to reason about subsampled time-series, continuous-time Granger non-causality and local independence. Finally, we discuss how constraint-based causal discovery algorithms (PC, FCI, CCD, CCI) apply directly to SDEs within our framework when conditional independence between sample paths can be consistently tested.
Read the full abstract

Statistical Methodology

Extracting Bayesian Evidence from Frequentist p-Values

The $p$-value and the Bayes factor are measures of evidence that are often considered to be philosophically and mathematically incompatible: The $p$-value quantifies conflict between data and $H_0$ ("surprise"), whereas the Bayes factor quantifies the relative predictive accuracy of $H_0$ versus $H_1$ ("evidence"). We revisit Jeffreys's Approximate Bayes factor (JAB) – a simple, largely overlooked approximation dating back to the 1930s – which connects these two paradigms for objective hypothesis testing of the existence of an effect. Under a unit-information prior the approximation requires only the $p$-value and the effective sample size $n_\text{eff}$. We clarify the core assumptions and boundary conditions for the application of JAB and show across 704 published $t$-tests and 39 comparisons of proportions that JAB approximates objective Bayes factors remarkably well. The connection between $p$-values and JAB has a practical implication: The evidence implied by a $p$-value depends strongly on $n_\text{eff}$. Conventional verbal labels for $p$-values (e.g., "strong surprise" for .001 < $p$ < .01) correspond to similarly graded Bayes factors only around $n_\text{eff} \approx 8$; for larger samples the same $p$-value implies weaker evidence. In moderately sized to large samples, $p > .10$ can amount to moderate or even strong evidence for $H_0$. JAB offers a cheap, sample-size-sensitive supplement to $p$-values, computable from routinely reported statistics, that remains valid even under optional stopping.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics) · Cross-listed from eess.SP

Dynamic Online Processor-Native Inference for State Estimation

Sensor-rich data-driven applications increasingly use Bayesian approaches to infer latent states of dynamic systems from noisy sensor measurements and physical models. Yet the computation of the likelihood remains an essential bottleneck for accurate posteriors and performant inference. This paper presents a Bayesian filtering technique that uses processor-native uncertainty tracking for both uncertainty propagation and inference. The technique implements deterministic hierarchical importance restructuring through a native operation, giving deterministic latency and bounded memory use for arbitrary models written as program code. Benchmarks across three nonlinear state-space systems compare the approach against particle filters and Monte-Carlo-based likelihood estimators. The technique enables deterministic approximate filtering with as high as 805$\times$ average speedup against direct Monte Carlo work at matched result quality for model evaluation, and Pareto-dominant accuracy-latency trade-offs for posterior inference while remaining competitive in RMSE with baseline particle filters.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics)

Learning the Graphical Nature of Symmetries

Finite groups are rigid algebraic objects, whose Cayley graphs expose a rich network geometry through which group-theoretic structure can be measured, compared, and learned. In this paper, a dataset of $131{,}406$ Cayley graphs is constructed, covering all groups of order at most $767$ except order $512$, recording exact algebraic labels for group properties together with a broad collection of graph, cycle, distance, and spectral statistics. This census aims to provide novel benchmarks for studying how finite-group properties are reflected in Cayley graph observables. It also yields new enumerative contributions: alongside recovering known OEIS sequences for standard group classes, new sequences for monolithic groups and for groups generated by at most three, four, and five elements are contributed to the OEIS. The accompanying network analysis identifies several empirical regularities and formulates testable conjectures, including relationships involving square clustering, Cayley graph diameter, average graph disorder, and spectral eigengaps of nilpotent groups. Finally, a comparison between classical models, an MLP, and graph neural network architectures is performed for predicting algebraic group properties directly from Cayley graph data. The results show that engineered graph statistics are highly informative, while GNNs, especially GIN and in some fixed-order settings GCN, can recover substantial structural signal directly from the graph. Such that graph-aware architectures show phases of optimality on these group-theoretic graph representations.
Read the full abstract

All authors Rashid Barket, Enrico Grimaldi, Yacoub Hendi, Edward Hirst, Adam Onus, Harmeet Singh

Machine Learning (Statistics) · Cross-listed from cs.LG

Are we Merging the Right Models? Impact of Expert Training Duration on Model Merging for LLMs

Multi-task model merging combines separately trained expert models into a single model that handles all tasks without co-training. Standard practice merges experts at their optimal validation loss. We challenge this convention by systematically studying how training duration of domain experts affects the quality of the merged model. We fine-tune experts on five domains (Math, Code, Instruction Following, Multilingual, and Safety) across three model sizes (Qwen 3.5 0.8B, 2B, and 4B), saving checkpoints from 25% to 500% of the optimal training steps and evaluating five merging methods at each duration. Our findings reveal a striking method-dependent pattern: simple averaging degrades sharply with overfitting, while sparsification-based methods achieve their best performance well past the validation optimum. We formalize this through bias-variance decomposition analysis, drawing a parallel to random forests where averaging benefits from high-variance individual learners. These results suggest that training duration and merging method should be chosen jointly rather than independently.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics) · Cross-listed from econ.EM

Removable Defects: The Economics and Limits of Deliberate Deficiency

A specialist tolerates blind spots that a generalist does not. Usually this is treated as a cost to be minimized. We treat it as a design variable: a deficiency can be kept because it pays and removed on demand in the rare situation where it would be fatal, by routing to a compensation channel. We give three results. First, an advantage condition under which keeping the deficiency is a computable economic position; structurally it is the Ehrlich-Becker market-vs-self-insurance margin applied to a competence gap, with the detector as a Townsend costly-state-verification technology. Second, a two-sided characterization of removability. A coupling lemma shows that when the deficiency is a coarsening of perception, no switch can separate benefit from harm, yielding a converse (a confounded detector earns zero premium, and any within-defect policy insisting on positive premium is driven, under multiplicative dynamics, to negative long-run growth) and an achievability result (a detector outside the deficiency earns a positive premium). Together, over structured uncertainty classes with severity capped or miss rate O(1/L): a defect is profitably removable iff the detector-relevant distinction survives the restriction and the advantage condition holds; the premium is the support function of the class's ROC set at an economic price vector. Third, observation defects and capacity defects differ exactly on whether access to the deployment distribution rescues them; the gap decomposes as cross-leak plus a closure deficit, and per-task randomization buys back the latter, never the former. The detector can be learned from declared fatal categories at a training bill linear in loss severity (up to a log factor). The results synthesize Chow's reject option, Kelly growth under ruin, and selective prediction.
Read the full abstract

Statistics Applications

Improved Global Ocean Heat Content Estimation by Modeling Vertical Spatio-Temporal Dependence

Estimating ocean heat content (OHC) with reliable uncertainties is critical for understanding and monitoring the evolution of Earth's climate, as the ocean has stored most of the energy accumulated in the climate system due to Earth Energy Imbalance. Here, we use Argo profiling float data from 2004-2022 to map OHC. As fewer Argo observations are available deeper in the water column, previous studies have partitioned the ocean into at least two pressure layers and mapped each separately, which complicates the estimation of uncertainties when the maps are summed to get the total OHC. In this work, we consider the case of two pressure layers and propose an improved mapping and uncertainty quantification method using bivariate locally stationary Gaussian processes and conditional simulations to map the two sections jointly while accounting for the correlation between them. We find that modeling this correlation results in improved OHC anomaly mapping and up to a 15 percent reduction of global OHC anomaly uncertainties in comparison to mapping the two layers separately without accounting for their dependence. These estimated uncertainties are essential to analyze the statistical significance of OHC anomalies on both regional and global scales, which we demonstrate using several climatological case studies.
Read the full abstract

Statistical Computation

Tutorial for Bayesian Factor Models

Bayesian Factor Models (BFM) are well-established models that decompose the observed variability in a set of mean-zero, independent, and uncorrelated factors (random effects). While Factor Analysis (FA) was introduced in 1904 by Spearman, there has been renewed interest in inferential and computational methods that can adapt to large and complex modern data sets that are now routinely collected in a variety of applications. We provide reproducible, harmonized, and fast software for a variety of recent BFMs that allows the direct comparison of methods and provides a one-stop tutorial for the BFMs and their implementation. We neither endorse nor recommend any of the methods for a particular application; we simply provide a previously unavailable harmonized and reproducible common platform for BFMs. The accompanying factorverse R package is available at https://github.com/peterdunson/factorverse.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics) · Cross-listed from cs.LG

Relaxing Faithfulness with Intervention-Only Causal Discovery

Causal discovery algorithms learn a network that describes the causal dependencies among random variables. A common workflow involves first utilizing conditional independence properties on observational data to determine partially directed causal relationships, then applying interventions to orient the unknown causal directions. A critical assumption for the first step is faithfulness: a requirement that causally linked variables exhibit statistical dependence. Many natural systems include buffering and stabilizing pathways that cancel out to achieve systemic robustness. This cancellation of pathways violates faithfulness, leading causal discovery algorithms to incorrectly remove causal dependencies. In this paper, we argue that hard interventions contain information about the presence/absence of causal linkage that is overlooked in the first stage of structure discovery. We show that a mild assumption – called intervention-immediacy faithfulness – that allows cancellations, is sufficient to nonparametrically identify causal structures with hard interventions. These results position interventions as the primary carriers of information about causal structure, which should take precedence over conditional independence testing. To flip the paradigm, we also specify equivalence classes when the identification criteria are not met due to limitations in the scope of interventions.
Read the full abstract

Other Statistics

The Evolution and Interpretation of "Statistical Purposes"

National Statistical Organizations (NSOs) and other groups often use the term "for statistical purposes only" in communication with prospective respondents, data users and other stakeholders. This term also provides an important anchor for many NSO decisions on operations and ethics. Although public communication often omits a clear operational definition of this term, this paper will show that reviews of underlying laws and policies identify two predominant criteria: (1) production of statistical information about relatively large population aggregates, with the intention of creating a general public benefit; and (2) protection of the confidentiality of data collected about data subjects and a related prohibition against the use of information provided by or about data subjects for legal or regulatory action against those individuals or organizations. We then explore how this term exists, and is often interpreted, within a much broader landscape of legal requirements and of scientific and professional codes of practice, and provide a broader definition for consideration based on these and other ethical frameworks. This paper closes by highlighting several areas that warrant further discussion to better position NSOs to navigate these challenges in the future.
Read the full abstract

All authors Michael B. Hawes, John L. Eltinge, Paul S. Marck, Danielle C. Neiman, Sallie Ann Keller

Statistics Applications

Multiple Instrument Methods Comparison by Precision weighted Deming Regression

In methods comparison (MC) studies, specimens are tested using two or more instruments with the objective of establishing the statistical relationship between the different instruments readings. Unlike regular regression, this is an errors in variables problem. Relationships may be fitted parametrically (Deming regression) or non-parametrically (Passing Bablok or PB regression.) In clinical chemistry settings, the measurement variability is rarely constant, but generally increases with increasing analyte values. Precision weighted Deming regression models this variability and incorporates it into the fitting. The simplest setting of comparing two instruments is discussed in (1) and implemented in an R package (2). PB makes minimal distributional assumptions. Its classical two-instrument implementation has recently been extended to multiple instruments (3). This work extends the two-instrument Deming model of (1) to multiple instruments, developing algorithms for fitting, for formal inference, for residual analysis, and for outlier detection and diagnosis.
Read the full abstract

Statistics Theory

A uniform relative deviation inequality for VC-subgraph classes

We establish a new Bernstein-type deviation inequality for classes of functions whose complexity is characterized through subgraphs. The inequality is non-asymptotic, involves explicit constants, and features a relative normalization by the probability level. Applied to kernel density estimation, it produces a location and bandwidth-adaptive error bound between the estimator and the smoothed density, holding simultaneously over all points on the real line and all positive bandwidths. The proof is elementary, combining a new symmetrization principle, which incorporates the relative normalization, with the maximal sub-Gaussian inequality, and requires neither concentration nor entropy-integral arguments. When specialized to classes of sets, our technique improves the constants in the classical Vapnik-Chervonenkis inequality with relative deviation of Anthony and Shawe-Taylor (1993), reducing the factor 4 S A (2n) to S A (2n) in the right-tail inequality and to 3 S A (2n) in the left-tail inequality.
Read the full abstract

Statistical Methodology

Calibrated Horizon-Weighted Local Projection Designs for Markov Switchbacks

We study temporal assignment design for Markov switchback experiments when the reported object is a dynamic local-projection target. We develop a calibrated selector that chooses the feasible persistence minimizing the covariance, HAC, residual-bootstrap, or realized-schedule risk of the estimator and reporting object specified before the experiment. A balanced homoskedastic Markov benchmark yields a closed form because the lagged-assignment information matrix is AR(1)-Toeplitz with a tridiagonal inverse. The benchmark maps local-projection reporting weights into persistence recommendations within a prespecified first-order Markov class. Field recommendations replace the benchmark covariance with residualized, serially dependent, pilot-calibrated, or randomization-based risk. A semi-synthetic Low Carbon London evaluation uses observed half-hourly baseline dynamics and known injected responses to assess design risk. It evaluates the covariance calculations under realistic load autocovariance and identifies when calibrated covariance selection should replace the homoskedastic Markov formula. Near-boundary designs use randomization-first inference when many-spell normal approximations are unsupported.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics)

Diversified Multinomial Logit Contextual Bandits

Existing contextual multinomial logit (MNL) bandits model relevance-driven choice but ignore the potential benefits of within-assortment diversity, while submodular/combinatorial bandits encode diversity in rewards but lack structured choice probabilities. We bridge this gap with the $\textit{diversified multinomial logit}$ (DMNL) contextual bandit, which augments MNL choice probabilities with a generally submodular diversity function, thereby formalizing the relevance–diversity trade-off within a single model. Incorporating diversity renders exact MNL assortment optimization intractable. We propose a $\textit{white-box}$ UCB-based algorithm, $\texttt{OFU-DMNL}$, that constructs assortments item-wise by maximizing optimistic marginal gains, avoids black-box optimization oracles. We show that $\texttt{OFU-DMNL}$ achieves at least a $(1-\frac{1}{e+1})$-$\textit{approximate}$ regret bound $\tilde{O}\left(d \sqrt{T/K}\right)$, where $d$ is the context dimension, $K$ the maximum assortment size, and $T$ the horizon, and attains an improved approximation factor over standard submodular baselines. Experiments demonstrate consistent gains and, relative to exhaustive enumeration, comparable regret with substantially lower runtime. Overall, DMNL bandits provide a practical foundation for diversity-aware assortment optimization under uncertainty, and $\texttt{OFU-DMNL}$ offers a statistically and computationally efficient solution.
Read the full abstract

Machine Learning (Statistics) · Cross-listed from cs.LG

Bet on Features: Anytime-Valid and Feature-Aware Auditing of Conditional Quantile Forecasters

Black-box conditional quantile forecasts are widely used for sequential decisions under asymmetric costs, such as inventory planning in supply chain management. Once deployed, such forecasters must be monitored continuously as data streams drift and regimes change; this invalidates standard, fixed-horizon backtests for calibration. Further, existing backtests do not take into account that the notion of calibration is, in fact, information-dependent: forecasts can look calibrated to an auditor with coarse information while being miscalibrated to an auditor with richer information. We develop a distribution-free and game-theoretic testing framework for continuously auditing black-box conditional quantile forecasters with non-i.i.d. losses, such that the resulting evidence process is powerful against predictably chosen alternatives specified by the features available to the auditor. We first formalize notions of conditional quantile calibration when different sets of features are available to the auditor, establishing that the coarseness of the auditor's information set determines the hardness of the testing problem. We then identify the sets of alternatives for which the auditor can achieve power, and focusing on contextual bets linear in the features, we derive finite-time detection guarantees for such alternatives, all without an i.i.d. assumption. The resulting evidence processes are interpretable at the feature level, as they quantify fine-grained, "feature-aware" evidence for miscalibration. We empirically validate these methods on simulated and real data, finding that a popular time series forecaster (Chronos-2) is highly miscalibrated w.r.t. multiple relevant features.
Read the full abstract

All authors Ivane Antonov, Sohom Mukherjee, Richard Pibernik, Yo Joong Choe