Analysis of PDEs
Papers
Fresh from arXiv, typeset properly. Highlighted words trade on the market.
Tuesday 24 March
Under sharp conditions, we prove the existence and refined asymptotic behaviour near zero (resp., at infinity) for all positive radial solutions to elliptic equations such as \begin{equation}\label{eq11} \tag{*} \mathbb L_{\rho,\lambda}(u)=\Delta u+ (2-N-2\rho)\, \frac{x\cdot \nabla u}{|x|^2}+ \frac{\lambda}{|x|^2}u=|x|^{\theta}\,u^q\, |\nabla u|^m\quad \mbox{in } \Omega\setminus\{0\}, \end{equation} where $\Omega=B_R(0)$ (resp., $\Omega=\mathbb R^{N}\setminus B_{1/R}(0)$) for $R>0$ and $N\geq 2$. The dynamics of such solutions is very rich since $\rho, \lambda,\theta\in \mathbb R$ are arbitrary, $ m>0$, $q\geq 0$ and $\kappa:=m+q-1>0$. To our knowledge, this is the first study of the local properties of the positive solutions of \eqref{eq11} with arbitrary $m>0$ and $\lambda\not=0$. We identify all profiles near zero (and at infinity via a modified Kelvin transform) under optimal conditions, depending on how $\Theta:=(\theta+2-m)/\kappa$ relates to $0$ or the roots $\Theta_\pm$ of $t^2+2\rho t+\lambda$ when $\lambda\leq \rho^2$. For each profile, we advance new methods that unearth the higher order terms in the asymptotic expansion. We highlight two new asymptotic profiles near zero due to the competition between the Hardy potential with $\lambda>0$ and the gradient-dependent absorption: (i) a blow-up profile $\left[ \lambda \left( \frac{\kappa}{m} \right)^m \right]^{\frac{1}{\kappa}} | \log |x||^{\frac{m}{\kappa}} $ if $\Theta=0$ and (ii) a bounded profile if $\Theta<0$. Any radial solution of \eqref{eq11} with $\lim_{r\to 0^+} u(r)=\gamma\in \mathbb R_+$ satisfies $(P_\pm)$ $u(r)=\gamma\pm \lambda^{1/m} \gamma^{1-\kappa/m} (1/\sigma)\, r^\sigma(1+o(1))$ as $r\to 0^+$, where $\sigma=-\kappa \Theta/m$. For any $\gamma\in \mathbb R_+$, there is $R>0$ such that \eqref{eq11} has a radial solution (infinitely many) satisfying $(P_-)$ ($(P_+)$).
Metric Geometry
CAT(0) spaces quasi-isometric to Euclidean spaces
We show that if a proper, geodesically complete, CAT(0) homology manifold is quasi-isometric to the Euclidean space R^n then it is homeomorphic to R^n. On the other hand, we show that there exist proper, geodesically complete, CAT(0) spaces quasi-isometric to R^n, which are not homeomorphic to it. We prove that our example is sharp in a suitable sense. Finally, we provide an example of a sequence of proper, geodesically complete, CAT(0) spaces that are not homology manifolds and that converge in the Gromov-Hausdorff sense to a topological manifold: this shows that the set of topological manifolds is not open in the class of proper, geodesically complete, CAT(0) spaces.
Read the full abstract
Functional Analysis
Entropy and Minimax Risk of Hypoelliptic Pseudodifferential Operators
We characterize the entropy and minimax risk of a broad class of compact pseudodifferential operators. Under suitable decay and regularity conditions on the symbol, we combine a Weyl-type asymptotic relation between the eigenvalue-counting function and the phase-space volume of the symbol with a general correspondence between spectral quantities, entropy, and minimax risk for compact operators. This approach yields explicit asymptotic formulae for both entropy and minimax risk directly in terms of the symbol. As an application, we derive sharp entropy and minimax risk asymptotics for unit balls in Sobolev spaces on unbounded domains, thereby extending Pinsker's theorem for Sobolev classes beyond the bounded-domain setting, and showing that the sharp asymptotic constants are determined by phase-space geometry rather than domain geometry.
Read the full abstract
Combinatorics
Constructing/analyzing differential distributed lattices
We restate a process presented by Stanley as a technique to prove that there exists exactly one $d$-differential distributive lattice for any positive integer $d$. This process can be trivially extended to apply to distributive finitary lattices that have a variety of differential poset structures. It can be viewed as an algorithm for constructing such lattices. Alternatively, it can be viewed as an algorithm for analyzing and characterizing such lattices. We show that the process can be used to prove properties of all weighted-differential lattices with positive weights. We present this with the hope that this approach can be used as the basis for a complete characterization of distributive lattices with a weighted-differential structure with positive weights.
Read the full abstract
Optimization and Control
Risk-Aware LQR with Temporally Coupled States
We formulate and solve a discrete-time linear-quadratic regulation (LQR) problem in a finite horizon thatpenalizes temporal variability and stochastic variability of the state trajectory. Our approach enables one to strike a balance between regulating the state and reducing temporal variability, with explicit sensitivity to risk. We achieve this by extending a risk measure called predictive variance to a setting with temporally coupled states. Numerical examples demonstrate the effect of temporal coupling in both risk-aware and risk-neutral control settings.
Read the full abstract
Probability · Cross-listed from stat.ML
Wasserstein Parallel Transport for Predicting the Dynamics of Statistical Systems
Many scientific systems, such as cellular populations or economic cohorts, are naturally described by probability distributions that evolve over time. Predicting how such a system would have evolved under different forces or initial conditions is fundamental to causal inference, domain adaptation, and counterfactual prediction. However, the space of distributions often lacks the vector space structure on which classical methods rely. To address this, we introduce a general notion of parallel dynamics at a distributional level. We base this principle on parallel transport of tangent dynamics along optimal transport geodesics and call it “Wasserstein Parallel Trends”. By replacing the vector subtraction of classic methods with geodesic parallel transport, we can provide counterfactual comparisons of distributional dynamics in applications such as causal inference, domain adaptation, and batch-effect correction in experimental settings. The main mathematical contribution is a novel notion of fanning scheme on the Wasserstein manifold that allows us to efficiently approximate parallel transport along geodesics while also providing the first theoretical guarantees for parallel transport in the Wasserstein space. We also show that Wasserstein Parallel Trends recovers the classic parallel trends assumption for averages as a special case and derive closed-form parallel transport for Gaussian measures. We deploy the method on synthetic data and two single-cell RNA sequencing datasets to impute gene-expression dynamics across biological systems.
Read the full abstract
Complex Variables
Optimal universal growth for integral means of normalized logarithmic derivatives in the Carathéodory class
We determine the optimal universal growth scale for the integral means of normalized logarithmic derivatives in the Carathéodory class. This resolves a problem of D.~K.~Thomas.
Numerical Analysis
Orthogonal polynomials for the de Rham complex on the disk and cylinder
This paper constructs polynomial bases that capture the structure of the de Rham complex with boundary conditions in disks and cylinders (both periodic and finite) in a way that respects rotational symmetry. The starting point is explicit constructions of vector and matrix orthogonal polynomials on the unit disk that are analogous to the (scalar) generalised Zernike polynomials. We use these to build new orthogonal polynomials with respect to a matrix weight that forces vector polynomials to be normal on the boundary of the disk. The resulting weighted vector orthogonal polynomials have a simple connection to the gradient of weighted generalised Zernike polynomials, and their curl (i.e. vorticity or rot) is a constant multiple of the standard Zernike polynomials which are orthogonal with respect to $L^2$ on the disk. This construction naturally leads to bases in cylinders with simple recurrences relating their gradient, curl and divergence. These bases decouple the de Rham complex into small exact sub-complexes.
Read the full abstract
Rings and Algebras
The PI Property in Algebras of Polynomial Type
In this article, we study the PI property for several families of noncommutative algebras of polynomial type. Specifically, we review criteria for the PI property in double Ore extensions, two-parameter quantum Heisenberg algebras, two-parameter quantum matrix algebras, the algebra $U_q^+(B_2)$, multiparametric quantum Weyl algebras, biquadratic algebras with three generators, Noetherian Down–Up algebras, and the recently introduced algebras $B_q(f)$. In several cases, we include detailed proofs of known results, provide proofs of some identities used in the literature, and present alternative proofs of results characterizing the PI property for some of these algebras. For Noetherian Down–Up algebras, we highlight the relationship between the PI property, finiteness over the center, and the FBN property. Finally, for the algebras $B_q(f)$, we prove that they admit a PBW basis and show that the PI property can be controlled in terms of the support of the polynomial $f$.
Read the full abstract
Geometric Topology
A Dunfield–Gong 4-Sphere is Standard
In this paper, we standardize a homotopy $4$-sphere constructed by Dunfield and Gong. As a corollary, we show that the $18$-crossing knot $18_{\text{nh}00000601}$, which is not known to be ribbon, is slice in the standard $4$-ball. Thus, $18_{\text{nh}00000601}$ serves as a potential counterexample to the Slice-Ribbon Conjecture. In addition, we show that the same knot bounds a fibered handle-ribbon disk in $B^{4}$.
Read the full abstract
Numerical Analysis
On two Abelian Groups Related to the Galois Top
In mathematical physics the Galois top, introduced by S. Adlaj, possesses a fixed point on one of two Galois axes through its center of mass. This heavy top has two algebraic motion invariants and an additional transcendental motion-invariant. This third invariant depends on an antiderivative of a variable in the canonical phase space. In this article an abelian semigroup and an abelian group are defined that are related to the application of the Huygens-Steiner theorem to points on the Galois axis of a rigid body. This yields non-linear representations of the one-dimensional, affine, linear (semi)group.
Read the full abstract
Commutative Algebra
On isotropy group of locally finite derivations on $\mathbb{K}[X,Y]$
In this paper, we study the isotropy groups of locally finite derivations of the polynomial ring $\mathbb{K}[X,Y]$, using Van den Essen's classification of locally finite derivations in two variables. We compare the isotropy group of a locally finite derivation with that of its associated exponential automorphism, showing that they coincide in the locally nilpotent case, whereas they may differ when the semisimple part is nontrivial. We also prove that every nonzero locally finite derivation has a nontrivial isotropy group.
Read the full abstract
Optimization and Control
Effective rates for continuous-time quasi-Fejér monotone dynamical systems
We provide quantitative convergence results for continuous-time dynamical systems in metric spaces that satisfy a continuous-time analog of quasi-Fejér monotonicity. More precisely, we provide a (strong) convergence result for such dynamical systems over compact metric spaces which is quantitatively outfitted with a continuous-time rate of metastability, which moreover can be explicitly and effectively constructed in a very uniform way, only depending on a few moduli representing quantitative witnesses to key properties of the dynamical system and a measure for the compactness of the space. We further show how this convergence result can be extended to non-compact spaces under a regularity assumption of the associated problem, where moreover rates of convergence can then be explicitly constructed which are similarly uniform. In both cases, already the associated “infinitary” convergence result is qualitatively novel in its present generality. Beyond this abstract quantitative theory for such dynamical systems, we motivate how the presently studied continuous-time variant of quasi-Fejér monotonicity naturally occurs as a unifying property of many dynamical systems and differential equations and inclusions, and in that way can be used to provide a comprehensive quantitative theory for many such dynamical systems. We illustrate this with three case studies for both classical first- and second-order dynamical systems in Hilbert spaces as well as (generalized) gradient flows and associated semigroups in nonlinear Hadamard spaces.
Read the full abstract
Dynamical Systems
On the Expansiveness of Invariant Measures under Pseudogroups
In this paper, we define and study weak expansive and expansive measures for pseudogroups, these two notions appear when analyzing the role of the generating set. We investigate the relations between such properties. We also provide a criterion for a measure to be weak expansive through the positivity of its entropy, generalizing the work of Arbieto and Morales. We also show that in some settings equicontinuous pseudogroups have no expansive measures.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Ramsey Theory and Bounding in Arithmetic
We explore the relation between various versions of Ramsey theorem and bounding schemes in model ${N}$ of a fragment of arithmetic $F$. Our goal is to recast, in a different framework, and extend some results of Hirst \cite{Hirst-1987}, see Theorem 1. We will extract Weihrauch reductions from Hirst's and similar proofs. Our results, informally stated in the our terminology, all inside ${N}$, follow: First the following are equivalent: $B\Sigma_2$, the finite union of finite c.e.\ sets is finite, and Infinite Pigeonhole Principle, see Theorem 3. We also discuss the Weihrauch relations between these logically equivalent principles, see Section 4. The Infinite Pigeonhole Principle is Weihrauch reducible to $RT^2_2$, see Theorem 4. There are also another principle logically equivalent to $B\Sigma_2$ which is Weihrauch reducible to $SRT^2_2$, see Theorem 5. We show that there is a principle which is equivalent with $B\Sigma_3$, see Theorem 6, and Weihrauch reducible to $SRT^2_{<\infty}$, Theorem 7. We discuss some equivalencies with $B\Sigma_{n-1}$, see Subsection 6.1, and then end with a problem Weihrauch reducible to $RT^{n+1}_{2}$, Subsection 6.2. The reader should be aware since we working within ${N}$ many of the standard definitions need to be adjusted to work. Due to the expository nature of this short paper, these definitions are sprinkled throughout the paper. A quick read of the paper from start to finish will provide a better understanding of the ideas involved rather than a careful reading of theorems.
Read the full abstract
Algebraic Geometry
Log purity, torsors on root stacks and log Nori fundamental group
We generalize the logarithmic purity theorem of Fujiwara-Kato-Mochizuki to torsors which arise in the Kummer log flat topology under finite flat linearly reductive group schemes. We then give a stack-theoretic interpretation of our purity theorem via root stacks, relating it to the valuative criterion of properness for tame algebraic stacks of Bresciani-Vistoli. Finally, we construct a logarithmic Nori fundamental group scheme of a log regular log scheme classifying such torsors, and compare it with the classical Nori fundamental group and the tame fundamental group.
Read the full abstract
Algebraic Topology
On the classifying space of a Morse flow category
We show that the classifying space of the flow category of a tame Morse function on a smooth, closed manifold $M$ recovers the homotopy type of $M$, thereby addressing a claim in a preprint of Cohen–Jones–Segal. The tameness assumption is that the compactified moduli spaces of broken gradient trajectories are locally contractible, ensuring the flow category is topologically well-behaved. We construct a Morse function and Riemannian metric on $S^2\times S^1$ for which the associated flow category fails to recover the correct homotopy type, showing that the tameness hypothesis is crucial. Together, these results clarify the extent to which transversality assumptions can be relaxed so that the flow category models the homotopy type of the underlying manifold.
Read the full abstract
Differential Geometry
On the generalization of biharmonic hypersurfaces and biharmonic curves
In this work, we extend the concepts of $p$-biharmonic maps and $p$-biharmonic hypersurfaces to provide a broader characterization of $(p,q)$-harmonic hypersurfaces and $(p,q)$-harmonic curves in Riemannian manifolds, including Einstein spaces. Moreover, we present new explicit examples of proper $(p,q)$-harmonic hypersurfaces and $(p,q)$-harmonic curves in space forms.
Read the full abstract
Numerical Analysis
Stochastic nonlocal traffic flow models with Markovian noise
We extend our recently introduced stochastic nonlocal traffic flow model to more general random perturbations, including Markovian noise derived from a discretized Jacobi-type stochastic differential equation. Invoking a deterministic stability estimate, we show that the arising random weak entropy solutions are measurable, ensuring that quantities such as the expectation are well-defined. We show that the proposed Jacobi-type noise is of particular interest as it ensures interpretability, preserves boundedness, and significantly alters the stochastic realizations compared to the previous white noise approach. Moreover, we introduce a local solution operator which provides information on the local effect of the noise and utilize it to derive a mean-value hyperbolic nonlocal PDE, which serves as a proxy for the mean value of the exact solution. The quality of this proxy and the impact of the noise process are analyzed in several simulation studies.
Read the full abstract
Combinatorics
Quadratic Embedding of Theta Graphs via Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces
Probability · Cross-listed from stat.AP
Dynamical behaviors of a stochastic SIS epidemic model with mean-reverting inhomogeneous geometric brownian motion
The main purpose of this paper is to study the Dynamical behaviors of a stochastic SIS epidemic model using mean-reverting inhomogeneous geometric brownian motion process. First we demonstrate the existence of a global-in-time solution and establish that is unique and remains positive. Then we derive a sufficient condition for exponential extinction of infectious diseases and we show that our extinction threshold in the stochastic case coincides with that of the deterministic case. Finaly, we define an appropriate theoretical framework to guarantee the existence of an ergodic stationary distribution.
Read the full abstract
Functional Analysis
Compact embeddings of variable exponent Sobolev, Besov, and Triebel-Lizorkin spaces on metric measure spaces
We study compact embeddings of Sobolev, Besov, and Triebel-Lizorkin spaces with variable exponents on both bounded and unbounded metric measure spaces. We establish sufficient conditions for compactness, and under additional assumptions, we show that they are also necessary. Moreover, we investigate the influence of isometry group actions on the compactness of embeddings. In particular, we answer the open question posed by P. Górka in [P. Górka, Looking For Compactness In Sobolev Spaces On Noncompact etric Spaces, Ann. Acad. Sci. Fenn., Vol 43, 2018, 531-540], proving a Berestycki-Lions type theorem.
Read the full abstract
Mathematical Physics · Cross-listed from nlin.SI
New soliton solutions for Chen-Lee-Liu and Burgers hierarchies and its Bäcklund transformations
Positive and negative flows of the Chen-Lee-Liu model and its various reductions, including Burgers hierarchy, are formulated within the framework of Riemann-Hilbert-Birkhoff decomposition with the constant grade two generator. Two classes of vacua, namely zero vacuum and constant non-zero vacuum can be realized within a centerless Heisenberg algebra. The tau functions for soliton solutions are obtained by a dressing method and vertex operators are constructed for both types of vacua. We are able to select and classify the soliton solutions in terms of the type of vertices involved. A judicious choice of vertices yields in a closed form a particular set of multi soliton solutions for the Burgers hierarchy. We develop and analyze a class of gauge-Bäcklund transformations that generate further multi soliton solutions from those obtained by dressing method by letting them interact with various integrable defects.
Read the full abstract
Mathematical Physics
Factorized dispersion relations for two coupled systems
We establish that the dispersion relations of any physical system composed of two coupled subsystems, governed by a space-time homogeneous Lagrangian, admit a factorized form G_{1}G_{2}=\gamma G_{\mathrm{c}}, where G_{1} and G_{2} are the subsystem dispersion functions, G_{\mathrm{c}} is the coupling function, and \gamma is the coupling parameter. The result follows from a determinant expansion theorem applied to the block structure of the coupled system matrix, and is illustrated through three examples: the traveling wave tube, vibrations of an airplane wing, and the Mindlin-Reissner plate theory. For the Mindlin-Reissner example we carry out a complete asymptotic analysis of the coupled dispersion branches, establishing that the factorized form provides a precise quantitative measure of mode hybridization: all four branches carry the imprint of both subsystem factors for any nonzero coupling, while asymptotically recovering the identity of pure uncoupled modes at large frequencies and wavenumbers. We further analyze the universal local geometry of the coupled dispersion branches near their intersection - the cross-point model - showing it is generically hyperbolic, and present a mechanical analog in which the wavenumber is replaced by a scalar parameter, exhibiting the same factorized structure and avoided crossin
Read the full abstract
Numerical Analysis · Cross-listed from cs.LG
Boost Like a (Var)Pro: Trust-Region Gradient Boosting via Variable Projection
Gradient boosting, a method of building additive ensembles from weak learners, has established itself as a practical and theoretically-motivated approach to approximate functions, especially using decision tree weak learners. Comparable methods for smooth parametric learners, such as neural networks, remain less developed in both training methodology and theory. To this end, we introduce VPBoost (Variable Projection Boosting), a gradient boosting algorithm for separable smooth approximators, i.e., models with a smooth nonlinear featurizer followed by a final linear mapping. VPBoost fuses variable projection, a training paradigm for separable models that enforces optimality of the linear weights, with a second-order weak learning strategy. The combination of second-order boosting, separable models, and variable projection give rise to a closed-form solution for the optimal linear weights and a natural interpretation of \VPBoost as a functional trust-region method. We thereby leverage trust-region theory to prove \VPBoost converges to a stationary point under mild geometric conditions and, under stronger assumptions, achieves a superlinear convergence rate. Comprehensive numerical experiments on synthetic data, image recognition, and scientific machine learning benchmarks demonstrate that \VPBoost learns an ensemble with improved evaluation metrics in comparison to gradient-descent-based boosting and attains competitive performance relative to an industry-standard decision tree boosting algorithm.
Read the full abstract
Statistics Theory
The Bernstein-von Mises theorem and efficiency for semiparametric inference in multivariate Hawkes processes
In this paper, we study semiparametric inference for linear multivariate Hawkes processes, a class of point processes widely used to describe self and mutually exciting phenomena. We establish a convolution theorem giving the best limiting distribution for a regular estimator of smooth functional. Then, in the Bayesian setting, we prove a semiparametric Bernstein-von Mises (BvM) theorem for nonparametric random series priors. We apply this result to histogram and wavelet based priors. Taken together, the convolution and BvM theorems show that, from a frequentist point of view, semiparametric Bayesian procedures have asymptotically the optimal behavior. Deriving the BvM property for random series priors led us to prove L2 posterior contraction, complementing for these priors the results of Donnet, Rivoirard and Rousseau (2020).
Read the full abstract
Metric Geometry
The Perimeter Winternitz Theorem in a Triangle
A variable line through the centroid G of a triangle divides the triangle into two parts each of whose lengths as a fraction of the perimeter fills a closed interval [m,1-m], with m between 0 and 1/2. We show that the range of m taken over all triangles is the interval (3/10,4/9], with 3/10 approached by scales of the triangles approaching the 5-4-1 triangle and their mid-size medians, and 4/9 attained by the equilateral triangles and the lines through G parallel to the sides. This result is the perimeter version of the classical Winternitz theorem for a triangle, asserting that, in the case of area-ratio instead of perimeter-ratio, m=4/9, and this is attained by all triangles and their lines through G and parallel to the sides.
Read the full abstract
Operator Algebras
Quantum Graph Theory by Example
Quantum graphs have been introduced by Duan, Severini, and Winter to describe the zero-error behaviour of quantum channels. Since then, quantum graph theory has become a field of study in its own right. A substantial source of difficulty in working with quantum graphs compared to classical graphs stems from the fact that they are no longer discrete objects. This makes it generally difficult to construct insightful, non-trivial examples. We present a collection of non-trivial quantum graphs that can be thought of in discrete terms, and that can be expressed in the diagrammatic formalism introduced by Musto, Reutter, and Verdon. The examples arise as the quantum graphs acted on by increasingly smaller classical matrix groups, and are parametrised by triples of matrices $(A, B, C)$. The parametrisation reveals a clean decomposition of quantum graph structure into classical and genuinely quantum components: $A$ and $C$ are described by a classical weighted graph called the strange graph, while $B$ provides a purely quantum contribution with no classical analogue. Based on this model, we give exact formulas or establish bounds for quantum graph parameters, such as the number of connected components, the chromatic number, the independence number, and the clique number. Our results provide the first large, parametric families of quantum graphs for which standard graph parameters can be computed analytically.
Read the full abstract
Functional Analysis
Coarea Reduction, Sparse Transfer, and Geometric Recomposition for Synchronized Singular Forms
We study truncated bilinear forms associated with synchronized kernels \[ K(x,y)=k(\phi(x),\psi(y)), \] where the singularity is governed by a one-dimensional kernel $k$, while the geometry is encoded by the phases $\phi$ and $\psi$. The central result of the paper is an architecture of exact reduction, analytic transfer, and geometric recomposition for this class of forms. First, we obtain an exact reduction at the level of pushforward measures and weighted pushforward measures in the level variable. Under absolute-continuity hypotheses, this reduction admits an effective realization in the Lebesgue layer, where control of the pushforward densities yields an abstract operator criterion for feeding estimates obtained in the reduced model back into the original problem. As a first complete realization of this scheme, we transfer to the synchronized setting a one-dimensional sparse domination principle for singular truncations with Dini-smooth kernels. The final geometric recomposition then separates two regimes: a uniform regime, where global consequences follow from quantitative control of the pushforward densities, and a critical regime, where degeneration of the phases near critical values forces a localized output weighted by pullbacks.
Read the full abstract
Functional Analysis
Approximation theorems in bilipschitz invariant theory
Bilipschitz invariant theory concerns low-distortion embeddings of orbit spaces into Euclidean space. To date, embeddings with the smallest-possible distortion are known for only a few cases, to include: (a) planar rotations, (b) real phase retrieval, and (c) finite reflection groups. Here, we prove that for all three of these cases, the smallest possible distortion is nearly achieved by a composition of a "max filter bank" with a linear transformation. Our proof amounts to a two-step process: first, we show it suffices to demonstrate a certain inclusion of Lipschitz function spaces, and second, we prove that inclusion, using fundamentally different approaches for the three cases. We also show that these cases interact differently with a few related function spaces, which suggests that a unified treatment would be nontrivial.