Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics · Cross-listed from physics.data-an
The Squealer: Sensification of model exploration and model misfit
Andrew Gelman, Andrew H. Jaffe, Eliot Carlson et al. (+1 more)
We introduce a method for visual and auditory feedback when exploring the fit of a model to data. Starting with a best-fit curve fit to data, the user can drag the curve to a new position and the computer will emit a squeal, becoming louder and more unpleasant as the discrepancy between curve and data increases. We demonstrate with four examples: a two-parameter curve fit to golf putting data, a four-parameter curve fit to dilution assays, a fit to cosmological data sensitive to the parameters of the Big Bang model, and a nonparametric Gaussian process fit to temperature readings.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Andrew Gelman, Andrew H. Jaffe, Eliot Carlson, Philip Greengard
Solar and Stellar Astrophysics
High Resolution Spectroscopic Analysis of Chromospheric Line Evolution during an Energetic Flare on AD Leo
Younghun Oh, Seo-Won Chang, Jongchul Chae et al. (+6 more)
Active M
dwarfs exhibit frequent and energetic
flares that provide a unique laboratory for studying chromospheric heating processes under extreme
magnetic activity. To probe the
flare process of M-
dwarfs, we present a high-resolution ($R\sim30{,}000$) spectroscopic case study of a superflare on AD Leo, detected on 2023 March 14 using the Bohyunsan Optical Echelle Spectrograph (BOES). Such high-energy events are rarely captured with simultaneous multi-line spectroscopy, allowing us to trace the energy partition and temporal
evolution of the chromospheric lines. Based on equivalent width variations, we found that the H$\alpha$ line radiated $8.8\times10^{30}$ erg, implying a total bolometric energy ($\sim10^{33}$ erg) comparable to the largest
solar flares. The Balmer series dominated the energy budget; the individual Ca II H and K lines contributed 47.5% and 26.2% of the H$\alpha$ energy, respectively, while each Ca II infrared triplet line emitted $\sim$17-19%. We confirm that the delayed peak emission, previously reported for Ca II H&K, also occurs in the Ca II triplet and Na I lines. These delays are consistent with the Neupert effect, suggesting that cumulative heating governs the gradual phase emission. While this superflare resembles
solar flares in general morphology, it also displayed systematic differences in chromospheric emission. It is likely that these differences reflect the distinct atmospheric structure and quiescent chromospheric conditions of M
dwarfs, rather than fundamentally different
flare physics.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Younghun Oh, Seo-Won Chang, Jongchul Chae, Juhyung Kang, Soosang Kang, Kyeore Lee, Kyoung-Sun Lee, Eun-Kyung Lim, Hyun-Il Sung
High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
Constraints on Hadronic Emission from Microquasars Detected by LHAASO
V. Vecchiotti, E. Amato, G. Giacinti et al. (+2 more)
Recently, the LHAASO collaboration reported ultra-high-energy (UHE) gamma rays from six microquasars. For five of these sources, the emission extends beyond $100$ TeV, making microquasars promising candidates for
Galactic PeVatrons. We investigate whether gamma-rays around $100$ TeV originate from hadronic interactions of accelerated
cosmic rays (CRs) with the ambient medium, and we estimate the contribution of these sources to the measured CR spectrum around the knee. We also place upper limits on six LHAASO microquasars with no detected UHE emission. We assume
diffusion-dominated propagation of CR, with a
diffusion coefficient suppressed compared to the average
Galactic value near the source and equal to the
Galactic value at large distances. We assume continuous injection over timescales of $t_{\rm age}=0.1-1$ Myrs. Using available measurements of the gas density, we find that hadronic interactions alone cannot fully account for the observed emission for any of the detected sources. However, in the case of GRS 1915+105 and MAXI J1820+070, the hadronic scenario may still be valid when considering acceleration efficiency higher than $10\%$. We then derive upper limits on the hadronic contribution to the observed gamma-ray flux. We estimate that the detected sources contribute at most $\sim4\%$ of the
Galactic CR spectrum at $1$ PeV for an injection timescales of $0.1$ Myrs and a CR acceleration efficiency of $10 \%$. When adopting the maximum acceleration efficiency allowed by the gamma-ray observations the contribution rises to $37\%$. Longer injection timescales ($\sim 1$ Myrs) lead to contributions exceeding the observational constraints. For sources not detected at UHE, we obtained a maximum contribution of $\sim 17\%$, achieved assuming continuous injection over $1$ Myr.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors V. Vecchiotti, E. Amato, G. Giacinti, G. Morlino, G. Peron
Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics
Superhorizon curvature perturbations in hybrid inflation revisited
Shi Pi and Anxianyi Xiong
We revisit cosmological perturbations in multi-field inflation using the $\delta N$ formalism. By extending the analysis to directions transverse to the inflationary trajectory, we explicitly account for the geometry of the final hypersurface. Applying this framework to hybrid inflation, we identify an enhancement mechanism of the
curvature perturbation driven by the growing isocurvature perturbation due to the tachyonic instability of the waterfall field. This amplification occurs during the trajectory's turn in field space, a process qualitatively distinct from the non-attractor solution in single-field inflation models such as ultra-slow-roll. The resulting power spectrum features a broad peak with a characteristic $k^3$ infrared growth and a ultraviolet spectral tilt that uniquely determines the nonlinear parameter $f_\mathrm{NL}$ of a logarithmic non-Gaussianity, all of which are primarily governed by the waterfall dynamics. We found that in hybrid inflation, the sign of $f_{\rm NL}$ is fixed by tachyonic waterfall geometry and is always positive, leading to a generic enhancement of
primordial black hole formation. The enhanced
curvature perturbation can simultaneously account for
primordial black hole dark matter and a
stochastic gravitational wave background detectable by LISA, Taiji, and TianQin.
Read the full abstract ▾
Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics
Design Method of Quasi-Lumped Element Bandpass Filters Using Superconducting Coplanar Waveguide for Millimeter-Wave Multichroic Imaging
Shinsuke Uno, Kah Wuy Chin, Tai Oshima et al. (+6 more)
An on-chip band-defining filter coupled with a superconducting
photon detector is a promising technology for developing multi-band imaging cameras at millimeter and submillimeter wavelengths. In this paper, we present the design of on-chip bandpass filters based on coplanar waveguide geometry, which can be easily integrated into large-format multi-band detector arrays. A lumped element filter design is suitable not only for achieving a compact footprint but also for suppressing harmonics to reduce band-to-band crosstalk in a multiplexer. However, the coplanar waveguide geometry and the photolithography process rule limit the maximum available inductance and capacitance of lumped elements, which does not sufficiently meet the requirements of filter
circuits. To overcome this limitation, we have established a design method for quasi-lumped element filters, in which the maximum element size is relaxed to a quarter wavelength, exceeding the ideal lumped element size. We achieved design solutions for 150, 220, and 270 GHz 8th-order Chebyshev bandpass filters and a triplexer. We also report on the measurement results of a scaled model of the bandpass filter, demonstrating the validity of our proposed filter design.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Shinsuke Uno, Kah Wuy Chin, Tai Oshima, Satoshi Ono, Takeshi Sakai, Kazuki Watanabe, Shuhei Inoue, Tatsuya Takekoshi, Kotaro Kohno
Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics
Broadband anti-reflection coating for sub-terahertz optics using dielectric multilayers
Toyo Naganuma, Shinsuke Uno, Shuhei Inoue et al. (+4 more)
Sub-terahertz astronomy requires instruments capable of simultaneous observations across multiple spectral bands, motivating the development of broadband anti-reflection coatings (ARCs). We investigated low-loss dielectrics with refractive indices suitable for multilayer ARCs on polyethylene optical elements and identified candidates that partially meet the requirements. To address the remaining gaps in available refractive indices, we applied dielectric multilayer synthesis by combining newly identified thin materials with controlled bonding to realize the required effective refractive indices. As a result, the fabricated 5-layer ARC achieved reflection losses of 0.2% (average) and 3.2% (maximum) over 130-710 GHz.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Toyo Naganuma, Shinsuke Uno, Shuhei Inoue, Kazuki Watanabe, Tatsuya Takekoshi, Takeshi Sakai, Tai Oshima
Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics
GLTCAM: Concept of Multi-color Millimeter and Submillimeter Camera for the Greenland Telescope
Shuhei Inoue, Tatsuya Takekoshi, Shinsuke Uno et al. (+12 more)
To investigate the formation history of large-scale structure through the dynamics of
galaxy clusters, we are developing a multi-color millimeter and submillimeter-wave continuum camera (GLTCAM) for deployment on the Green-land
Telescope (GLT). GLTCAM will observe in six frequency bands - three in the millimeter range (150, 220, and 270 GHz) and three in the submillimeter range (350, 400, and 670 GHz). The optical design provides a compact configuration that fits within the GLT receiver cabin, while delivering diffraction-limited performance over an $18'$ field of view with minimal telecentricity error and distortion. A key advantage of this design is its uniform illumination footprint at the cold stop, which helps minimize thermal loading on both the detectors and the cryogenic stages. The focal plane module comprises a quasi-optical bandpass filter, a conical horn array coupled with planar ortho mode transducers (OMTs), and a superconducting multi-color microwave kinetic inductance detector (MKID) array. Current development efforts are focused on the three-color millimeter-wave module. The detector array employs a single-layer coplanar waveguide (CPW) architecture, which simplifies fabrication and enables scalability to large-format arrays. GLTCAM aims for the early realization of next-generation wide-field, multi-color observations as a pathfinder for future large submillimeter
telescopes.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Shuhei Inoue, Tatsuya Takekoshi, Shinsuke Uno, Kazuki Watanabe, Taiki Sato, Toshihiro Tsuzuki, Satoru Mima, Tohru Taino, Kazuyuki Fujita, Shunichi Nakatsubo, Yuki Kimura, Chiko Otani, Ryohei Kawabe, Kotaro Kohno, Tai Oshima
Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics
Estimating Cosmological Parameters from Localized Fast Radio Bursts: A Method for Removing Milky Way Dispersion-Measure Contributions
Yuchen Zhang, Yang Liu, Hongwei Yu et al. (+1 more)
Fast
radio bursts (FRBs) are emerging as powerful probes for cosmology. However, cosmological inference based on FRB dispersion measures (DMs) is limited by uncertainties in the Milky Way contribution, including those from the
Galactic interstellar medium and the
Galactic halo. In this Letter, we propose a method that eliminates the Milky Way contribution by using DM differences between localized FRBs within the same sky region. The method removes the need to adopt a specific
Galactic electron-density model or a prior assumption for the
Galactic halo DM. We validate the reliability of the method using mock FRB samples and show that it successfully recovers the fiducial cosmological parameter. Applying the method to current localized FRB data, we obtain a constraint on $\Gamma \equiv \Omega_b H_0 f_{\rm d}$ that differs from that inferred using the conventional treatment of the Milky Way contribution. This difference highlights the importance of Milky Way DM systematics in FRB cosmology and demonstrates the potential of differential DM methods for future large samples of localized FRBs.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Yuchen Zhang, Yang Liu, Hongwei Yu, Puxun Wu
Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics
Modeling survey-window and integral-constraint effects on PNG in the galaxy power spectrum with light-cone mocks
Shintaro Nakano, Masahiro Takada, Toshiki Kurita et al. (+1 more)
We develop an analysis framework based on light-cone
galaxy mock catalogs constructed from linear theory simulations in order to accurately model the impact of
primordial non-Gaussianity (PNG) on
galaxy power spectrum on large scales. These linear light-cone catalogs properly incorporate a variety of observational and cosmological effects, including the survey window function, the
redshift evolution of matter and
galaxy density fields, and
redshift-space distortions (RSD). When estimating the multipole moments of the power spectrum from each light-cone mock, we employ the same
estimator as used in actual analyses, thereby properly accounting for the effects of the discrete
Fourier transform, the line-of-sight dependence of the fields, and wide-angle RSD effects. Using light-cone mock catalogs that mimic the BOSS survey, we demonstrate that long-wavelength modes comparable to or larger than the survey window scale, namely super-survey modes, have a significant impact on the integral constraint (IC) in power spectrum measurements. In particular, we show that the analytical treatment of the survey-window convolution and IC, which has been commonly used in previous studies, begins to lose accuracy on scales of $k\lesssim k_{\rm eq}$ (the matter-radiation equality scale), and becomes invalid in the presence of PNG. The method developed in this work enables unbiased searches for PNG using the
galaxy power spectrum on long-wavelength scales probed by ongoing and future wide-area
galaxy surveys.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Shintaro Nakano, Masahiro Takada, Toshiki Kurita, Ryo Terasawa
Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics · Cross-listed from cs.LG
ScaleAware-JEPA: Latent Representation for Discovery in Multiscale Physical Fields
Guang-Xing Li
Continuous physical fields represent a large fraction of data under scientific investigation. Their multiscale structures are central to discovery, yet useful coordinates are not known in advance. Standard self-supervised methods define context and targets in fixed image coordinates, posing a predictive task misaligned with fields organized across a continuous scale hierarchy. We introduce ScaleAware-JEPA, a framework that constructs dense, label-free latent coordinates for continuous scalar fields. Constrained
Diffusion Decomposition (CDD) separates each field into pixel-registered scale components and provides the scale coordinates that define the masking geometry. The resulting JEPA objective predicts hidden structure with a context footprint tied to the
diffusion scale of each component rather than to an arbitrary patch size. Across MHD
turbulence, interstellar molecular gas and urban nighttime-light structure, the learned geometry maps back to coherent morphology, forming dense structural atlases without labels or predefined
segmentation rules. By tying latent prediction to the scale hierarchy of a field, ScaleAware-JEPA constructs latent coordinates through which complex physical patterns can be inspected before their relevant structures have been prescribed. Code is available at https://github.com/gxli/SA-JEPA.
Read the full abstract ▾
High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena · Cross-listed from hep-ph
Size Dependence of the Sommerfeld Enhancement for Puffy Dark Matter
Wu-Long Xu, Jin Min Yang and Wen-Na Yang
We examine the size effects in the Sommerfeld enhancement factor for puffy dark matter annihilation. First, we use the partial-wave method to study the case of puffy dark matter for which only a charge density distribution is given without specifying its internal structure. We find that by using two dimensionless parameters, we can provide a characterization of the resonance structure of the Sommerfeld enhancement. Using this approach, we demonstrate that the finite size of dark matter particle is another fundamental factor, in addition to low velocity, that affects the Sommerfeld enhancement. Then, as an example of puffy dark matter with nontrivial internal structures, we perform the analysis for the nugget-type dark matter, whose Sommerfeld enhancement factor is found to exhibit a resonant behavior similar to that of point-like particles.
Read the full abstract ▾
Astrophysics of Galaxies
Globular cluster formation with multiple stellar populations: A comprehensive overview of a star-cloud interaction scenario
Kenji Bekki and Madeleine McKenzie
We present a new scenario of globular cluster (GC) formation with multiple
stellar populations (MPs) in which both the first and second populations (1P and 2P, respectively) of
stars form from
giant molecular clouds (GMCs) polluted by asymptotic
giant branch (AGB)
stars within and around the GMCs. Unlike previous GC formation scenarios with AGB
stars being the primary polluters, the new scenario alleviates tensions with the mass-budget and dilution-timing problems The principal results based on idealized analytic models of the formation scenario are as follows. The observed fraction of 1P
stars and the helium abundance spreads between the 1P and 2P as a function of GC masses can be well reproduced. The modelled GCs show O-Na, C-N, and Mg-Al anticorrelations and Si-Al, 25Mg-Al, 26Mg-Al correlations. The observed Mg-K anticorrelation can be reproduced, only if super AGB
stars make a significant contribution to chemical enrichment within GMCs. The lack of correlations of Li abundances with [Na/Fe] and [Al/Fe] can be reproduced, only if about 20% of the polluting AGB
stars produce Li-rich ejecta, which disfavours scenarios with polluters incapable of Li production. Iron-complex, Type-II GCs can be formed through merging of two GCs formed from two GMCs within a host
dwarf galaxy at different epochs. The new scenario predicts young massive clusters formed in
galaxy environments with surface
star formation rate densities well below 1 M_sun/yr/kpc^2 are unlikely to evolve into GCs with MPs. It also predicts low 12C/13C ratios of 2P (~5), a [Na/Fe]-[F/Fe] anticorrelation, and P-rich
star formation with [P/Fe]$>0.5$ and [N/Fe]>0.5. These predictions are tested against more than 30 observed properties of GCs with MPs, representing one of the most comprehensive observational
benchmarks against a specific GC formation scenario to date.
Read the full abstract ▾
Earth and Planetary Astrophysics
Deuterated water and the formation of the satellites of Uranus
Michael E. Brown, Matthew Belyakov, Swaroop Chandra et al. (+5 more)
The satellites of Uranus orbit in a low-eccentricity, equatorial plane that is tilted by 98 degrees relative to the
solar system – a geometry that mirrors Uranus's extreme axial tilt. Although a
giant impact could have tipped Uranus, how the satellites came to share this orientation remains uncertain. Proposed formation pathways include
primordial accretion followed by reorientation, formation from debris generated by the tilting impact, and reaccretion from a massive ring produced by the
tidal disruption of passing bodies from the outer
solar system. Current observations do not discriminate among these scenarios. Using the James Webb Space
Telescope, we measured the deuterium-to-hydrogen (D/H) ration in the water ice of the five regular satellites of Uranus. We find an average D/H ratio of $2.1\pm 0.2 \times 10^{-4}$, nearly five times higher than that of Uranus and comparable to the values measured in comets. This enrichment is inconsistent with with any formation scenario in which substantial Uranian material was incorporated into the satellites, thereby excluding models that require significant mixing in an impact-derived vapor disk. The observed D/H ratios are instead compatible with models in which the satellites accreted from material that remained largely separate from Uranus, such as debris from a disrupted pre-existing satellite system or from a tidally captured outer
solar system body. The innermost regular satellite, Miranda, exhibits a marginally elevated D/H ratio (2.8 $\sigma$ above the average of the other satellites), potentially indicating a distinct formation history or source of water and offering an important clue for distinguishing amount competing models.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Michael E. Brown, Matthew Belyakov, Swaroop Chandra, M. Ryleigh Davis, Merritt McDowell, Ashma Pandya, Kevin T. Trinh, Samantha K. Trumbo
High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
VLBI Astrometry of Magnetars
Takuya Akahori, Sujin Eie, Kei Amada et al. (+8 more)
The origin of the strongest
magnetic fields in the Universe, i.e., the origin of magnetars, is a longstanding question. An enhanced dynamo effect in an irregular
supernova explosion is a possible origin, which implies a stronger kick velocity and a higher proper motion of the magnetar compared to those of ordinary
pulsars as well as an irregular morphology of the host
supernova remnant (SNR). However, this hypothesis is not well studied yet, because there is a lack of precise measurement of the proper motion of magnetar and of identification of the host SNR. VLBI astrometry of magnetars is a unique tool to examine the hypothesis. In this chapter, we introduce the MONSTER (Monitoring Observations of the
Neutron Stars That Evolve Rapidly) Project. SKA-VLBI's unprecedented sensitivity and the highest angular resolution will allow us to dramatically expand the survey volume in which we can measure the proper motion of magnetars within a
radio outburst period of a few months.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Takuya Akahori, Sujin Eie, Kei Amada, Sangita Kumari, Kohei Kurahara, Hiroto Masaoka, Hao Ding, Teruaki Enoto, Shota Kisaka, Keiichi Maeda, Kotaro Niinuma
Astrophysics of Galaxies
Takuya Akahori, Kohei Kurahara, Shin-ya Nitta et al. (+4 more)
Galaxy clusters contain an intra-cluster medium (ICM) with temperatures of tens of millions of Kelvin. Cosmological structure formation simulations show that this diffuse gas is heated not only by adiabatic gravitational compression but also by shock waves and
turbulence generated during mergers of
galaxy groups and clusters. These processes are expected to produce
magnetic fields and
cosmic rays, observed through synchrotron polarization. One structure formed during cluster
evolution is the cold front, a contact discontinuity created when colder gas moves transonically through hotter gas. Using MeerKAT, GMRT, and ATCA, we recently discovered
radio emission along cold fronts in two
galaxy clusters, with spectra indicating re-acceleration at the discontinuity. This presents a new puzzle because the standard mechanism in
galaxy clusters,
Fermi acceleration, is not naturally expected there. We propose
magnetic reconnection as the re-acceleration mechanism. Compression and stretching of magnetized
plasma at the discontinuity can generate current sheets that trigger reconnection, as also suggested by simulations. With AA*, we will probe broadband
radio spectra at high spatial resolution to constrain where re-acceleration occurs. Polarization measurements will reveal
magnetic-field structures and clarify the conditions required for
magnetic reconnection.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Takuya Akahori, Kohei Kurahara, Shin-ya Nitta, Haruka Sakemi, Hiroki Akamatsu, Mami Machida, Motokazu Takizawa
Earth and Planetary Astrophysics
TOI-6884b: A low-mass brown dwarf transiting a slightly evolved star
Akanksha Khandelwal, Shubhendra Nath Das, Rishikesh Sharma et al. (+42 more)
We report the discovery of a low-mass transiting brown
dwarf orbiting TOI-6884 (TIC~156514476, $T_{\rm mag}=11.4$) from NASA's Transiting
Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) mission. The TESS light curves initially suggested an orbital period of $\sim$14.42~days; however, our high-precision ground-based radial velocity measurements and multi-epoch time-series photometry reveal this to be a harmonic alias. We determine the true orbital period to be $4.808264^{+0.000015}_{-0.000014}$~days and confirm the substellar nature of the companion. TOI-6884b has a mass of $26.32^{+0.98}_{-0.93}\,M_{\mathrm{J}}$, a radius of $0.927^{+0.51}_{-0.52}\,R_{\mathrm{J}}$, and resides on a nearly circular orbit ($e=0.067^{+0.010}_{-0.012}$). Its host
star is a late F-type slightly evolved
star with $M_\star = 1.410^{+0.075}_{-0.069}\,M_\odot$,\msun, $R_\star = 1.840^{+0.072}_{-0.073}\,R_\odot$, $\log{g} = 4.057^{+0.045}_{-0.039}$, $[{\rm Fe/H}] = 0.094^{+0.073}_{-0.068}$~dex, and $T_{\rm eff}=6330^{+180}_{-160}$,\mathrm{K}$. TOI-6884b is a key addition to the small population of well-characterized transiting brown
dwarfs orbiting host
stars that have evolved off the main sequence. The detection of such systems will contribute to our understanding of the dynamical histories and structural
evolution of short-period substellar companions around evolved
stars.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Akanksha Khandelwal, Shubhendra Nath Das, Rishikesh Sharma, Abhijit Chakraborty, Churchil Dwivedi, Sanjay Baliwal, Karen A.Collins, David W. Latham, Allyson Bieryla, Cristilyn N. Watkins, Felipe Murgas, Norio Narita, Enric Palle, Steve B. Howell, Mark E. Everett, Catherine A. Clark, Polina A. Budnikova, David Ciardi, Nikitha Jithendran, Akihiko Fukui, Ashirbad Nayak, Bob Massey, Boris Safonov, Florence Libotte, Francis P. Wilkin, Gregor Srdoc, Howard M. Relles, Ivan Bonilla-Mariana, Izuru Fukuda, Jason D. Eastman, Jerome de Leon, Jesus Higuera, Kapil Bharadwaj, Keith Horne, Kendra Nguyen, Kevikumar Lad, Manuel Pichardo Marcano, Micaela Magno, Neelam JSSV Prasad, Noriharu Watanabe, Richard P. Schwarz, Sam Quinn, Santiago Paez, Toshi Suganuma, Y. Gomez Maqueo Chew
Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics · Cross-listed from physics.hist-ph
What Naturalness Measures: Fine-Tuning and Informational Invariants in Cosmology and Dark Matter
Stefano Profumo
Naturalness is commonly presented as an objective constraint on physical theories: a model requiring fine-tuning is judged implausible. This presentation conflates a representation-dependent quantity with an invariant one. A fine-tuning verdict depends on the choice of fundamental parameters, the prior, and the measure convention, so it does not by itself fix a feature of the world. Here, I argue that what is objective is structural: the universality class of the map from parameters to observables, invariant under admissible changes of parametrization and measure convention, and independent of any prior over parameter space; it constitutes an informational invariant. On this account naturalness is neither an aesthetic preference nor an objective probability, but a statement about the distinguishability geometry of the representations through which physics encodes observation. I trace the certainty of naturalness verdicts to a tradition, from Ockham through Dirac and Weinberg, in which parsimony and beauty are taken as guides to truth; modern naturalness inherits that tradition's authority without its successive justifications. The argument is developed in the gravitational and cosmological sector, where naturalness
reasoning is sharpest and its effective-field-theory grounding is weakest. A uniform analysis across gravitational and particle dark matter candidates shows that fine-tuning tracks the analytic structure of the abundance map, not the nature of the candidate; that the resulting classification is invariant across measure conventions while the tuning number is not; and that this decomposition instantiates informational structural realism. I situate the position against the autonomy-of-scales account, which the argument largely accepts, and against the deflationary reading, which identifies the borrowed authority but discards the structural residue.
Read the full abstract ▾