General Economics · Cross-listed from cs.CL
Monocultural Biases: Correlated biases in large language models lead to unequal systemic exclusion rates in hiring
Matthew Bone, Fabian Stephany and Maria del Rio-Chanona
Employers are increasingly using large
language models (LLMs) to automate their hiring process. This paper investigates the risk of monocultural biases, in which the widespread deployment of large
language models homogenizes biases across the labor
market, leading to greater systemic exclusion for certain demographic groups. For ten LLMs, we measure hiring biases across their base and post-trained versions to identify which stage, pre-training or post-training, lead to monocultural biases. We find that, compared to their base models, post-trained models are 3.6% less likely to callback older applicants. This negative shift occurs in eight of the ten models that we evaluate. Post-trained models have much more correlated decisions than base models which is likely driven by human capital traits like skills or college major. However, greater consensus among models increases global systemic exclusion rates from 5.6% to 17.3% and exacerbates demographic inequalities, with intersectional systemic exclusion rates ranging from 12.2% to 21.7% for post-trained models. We find that this inequality is primarily driven by age-based discrimination that is exacerbated in post-training. These results indicate that while post-training techniques may improve models' abilities to select the best applicants, they may raise systemic inequality risks for those at the margin by uniformly introducing new biases.
Read the full abstract ▾
General Economics
The Italian Municipality Equitable and Sustainable Well-being Index (MESWI)
Nicola Caravaggio, Giuliano Resce and Agapito Emanuele Santangelo
This paper develops the Municipal Equitable and Sustainable Well-being Index (MESWI) for all Italian municipalities, extending the 12-domain BES framework to the local level through 49 indicators. Results reveal substantial territorial heterogeneity that regional and provincial statistics may conceal. The North-South divide remains the dominant geographical pattern and is considerably stronger than the difference between inner and non-inner areas. At the same time, municipalities within the same regions and territorial categories display markedly different well-being profiles. Remoteness is associated with weaker services and socio-economic opportunities but also with stronger environmental performance. The MESWI provides a fine-grained picture of multidimensional well-being and a potential information base for the programming, monitoring and evaluation of place-based policies.
Read the full abstract ▾
Theoretical Economics · Cross-listed from cs.GT
Simultaneous Envy and Equitability Guarantees
Hadi Hosseini, Shraddha Pathak, Lirong Xia et al. (+1 more)
Recent work in fair division has focused on either simultaneously satisfying closely related
fairness notions or achieving a single notion across the ex-ante and ex-post worlds. We study the compatibility of two fundamentally different
fairness notions: envy-freeness and equitability. For indivisible goods-only and chores-only settings, we study the existence and complexity of simultaneously satisfying their relaxations, revealing sharp contrasts between the two settings. For normalized binary goods, we give a
polynomial-time
algorithm for computing an EF1+EQ1 allocation with at most seven
agents, but also construct a normalized instance with a larger number of
agents for which no such allocation exists. In sharp contrast, binary chores admit the stronger EFX+EQX guarantee for any number of
agents, even without normalization. We further initiate the study of cross-notion ex-ante and ex-post guarantees, asking whether randomized allocations can provide ex-ante guarantees for one notion while preserving ex-post guarantees for another.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Hadi Hosseini, Shraddha Pathak, Lirong Xia, Chengkai Zhang
General Economics
An Anonymized Urn-Based Experimental Dataset on Decision-Making under Risk and Ambiguity
Václav Kratochvíl, Radim Jiroušek, Klára Šimůnková et al. (+1 more)
This data paper describes an anonymized release derived from controlled behavioral experiments on decision-making under risk (known probabilities) and ambiguous uncertainty (partially specified or unknown probabilities) in Ellsberg-type urn tasks. The release contains 4,486 decision records from 246 adult participant records across two implementations (laboratory and online). In each task, participants reported their maximum stake to enter a subsequent lottery; these stake responses can be interpreted as proxies for willingness to pay within the implemented incentive mechanism. In a subset of tasks, participants also selected the color they wished to bet on. The online implementation additionally includes ex-post evaluations of perceived uncertainty across situations. The repository further provides detailed game definitions, realized lottery outcomes, participant instructions, and a data dictionary of variables. The source export contained 4,544 decision records; 58 records belonging to five participants younger than 18 were excluded from this release because documentation of guardian permission for unrestricted public data publication was not available. The
dataset supports replication studies, comparisons of ambiguity-attitude models, and analyses of behavioral stability under repeated participation.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Václav Kratochvíl, Radim Jiroušek, Klára Šimůnková, Simona Bažantová
General Economics
The Dynamic Trade-Off of Dual-Class Shares
Hyunseob Kim, Doron Levit and Roni Michaely
Dual-class shares allocate control to founders whose firm-specific investments drive firm value but separate control from ownership, raising agency costs. We analyze this trade-off dynamically. Using new data on US dual-class firms spanning 52 years and difference-in-differences designs, we show that valuations rise following dual-class recapitalizations but decline over time, whereas innovative output increases persistently. These effects are concentrated in industries with greater firm-specific investments. We find corresponding results for stock unifications. Investment by mature dual-class firms is less sensitive to opportunities and voting premia increase with maturity. Our results support dynamic treatment effects and yield new policy implications.
Read the full abstract ▾
Theoretical Economics
Potentials and Weak Potentials in Acyclic and Weakly Acyclic Games
Igal Milchtaich
In a number of large, important families of finite games, not only is the set of pure-strategy Nash
equilibria nonempty but it is also reachable from any initial strategy profile by some sequence of myopic single-player moves to a better or best-reply strategy. This weak acyclicity property is weaker than acyclicity of the game, which requires every such sequence to reach an
equilibrium. For example, all perfect-information extensive-form games are weakly acyclic, but they are generally not acyclic as even sequences of best-improvement steps may cycle. Weak acyclicity is equivalent to acyclicity of some priority rule, which is a rule that allows only some improvement moves. It is also equivalent to the existence of a weak potential, which unlike a potential increases along some rather than every sequence as above.
Read the full abstract ▾
Econometrics · Cross-listed from cs.CE
Efficient tensor bases for pairwise comparisons
Konrad Kułakowski and Ryszard Smarzewski
In this study, we construct the first orthogonal basis for additively consistent subspace in pairwise comparisons theory. This construction is based on our representation of additively consistent best approximations of skew-symmetric
matrices with respect to a tensor basis having minimal support. The orthogonal basis establishes the logarithmic consistent projection for the orthogonal windowing of pairwise comparisons
matrices. It is compared with the windowing of the Saaty and SVD types. These comparisons resulted in new composite formulae for logarithmic, Saaty, and SVD projections. The theoretical considerations presented in the paper are accompanied by numerous examples.
Read the full abstract ▾
Econometrics
Cross-Section Estimation of Long-Run Relations Using Time-Compressed Data
Serena Ng and Nikolay Gospodinov
Many empirical investigations of long-run relations are based on cross-section regressions in averaged or long differenced data that effectively have the time dimension of a $T\times N$ panel compressed. We analyze a class of time-compressed I(1) data and show that they have magnified variability stemming from the fact that the cross-section variance of a non-stationary panel `fans out' with time. Cross-section regressions in time compressed data can potentially yield estimates that are super-consistent and asymptotically normal, whether the regressors are stationary, non-stationary, or highly persistent. The fastest convergence rate of $\sqrt{N}T$ requires a compression scheme that not only magnifies the non-stationary signal, but also dilutes the regression noise. Omitted fixed effects preclude noise dilution but the estimates remain super-consistent. However, the fanning out effect can be weakened when the data have a strong force for mean-reversion or convergence, a problem that seems relevant for temperature data. We consider three applications and find that the long-run relation between consumption and income, and between growth/inflation and demographic variables are reasonably well determined, but the estimated relation between growth and warming temperature is fragile.
Read the full abstract ▾
Econometrics
Nonparametric Bayesian Inference for Partially Identified Discrete Response Models
Elie Tamer and Christopher D. Walker
This paper proposes a nonparametric
Bayesian inference framework for partially identified discrete response models. The key observation is that these models map a reduced-form conditional choice probability to an identified set. Consequently, nonparametric
Bayesian inference for the conditional probability mass function leads to
Bayesian inference for the identified set. The inference framework nests conditional moment inequalities and linear systems with unknown coefficients as special cases. Importantly, our proposal does not require converting conditional moments into unconditional moments or discretizing
covariates. We show that the posterior is consistent for the true identified set when the model is correctly specified, show that the posterior can consistently detect model misspecification, and show posterior consistency for a pseudo-identified set that is valid under misspecification. We also verify the assumptions for a class of priors based on Gaussian processes that we use to implement our proposal. These priors offer similar flexibility to frequentist partial identification methods, and are computationally attractive because posterior sampling can be performed in closed-form. We also show that many of the ideas in this paper extend to continuous responses and aggregated discrete responses (e.g.,
market shares).
Read the full abstract ▾
Theoretical Economics
Agnostic Sequential Rationality
Igal Milchtaich
Agnostic sequential
equilibrium (ASE) is a refinement of sequential
equilibrium that does not force on the players a single, arbitrary belief system. In addition, whereas sequential
equilibrium assumes the players' beliefs to be fully consistent (a notion that is based on perturbations of strategies), ASE employs a novel, simpler and local concept of strong consistency between strategy profiles and off-
equilibrium beliefs, which is applicable to a large class of dynamic games, including games with a continuum of actions. In the last respect, the new solution concept is similar to perfect
Bayesian equilibrium. It is shown that a strategy profile in an imperfect-information extensive-form game with perfect recall is an ASE precisely when it is a sequential
equilibrium with every fully consistent belief system. ASE is generalized by the set-valued solution concept of agnostic sequential polyequilibrium, which allows leaving the players' actions in some information sets partially or completely unspecified.
Read the full abstract ▾
Econometrics
Endogenous Selection and Spillovers: Bayesian Inference for Policy-Relevant Causal Effects
Duong Trinh
This paper develops a new econometric framework to identify and estimate policy-relevant causal effects in contexts with endogenous selection into treatment and spillovers within single large networks or spatial settings. Conventional causal inference methods relying on either unconfoundedness or no-interference assumptions are generally inadequate in these scenarios. We introduce a Spillover Roy model that jointly models endogenous treatment selection and potential outcomes while allowing spillovers through a low-dimensional exposure mapping of neighbors' treatments. The model captures heterogeneous treatment responses across levels of latent resistance to treatment and neighborhood exposure. Within this framework, we define policy-relevant direct, spillover, and total effects under feasible policy changes and show that the total effect decomposes into a direct component from policy-induced participation and a spillover component from policy-induced changes in neighborhood treatment exposure. For estimation and inference, we develop a
Bayesian data-augmentation
algorithm with parameter expansion that enables efficient posterior computation and coherent uncertainty quantification for heterogeneous causal effects and policy counterfactuals. An application to the U.S. Opportunity Zones program finds positive direct effects on housing development but limited spillover benefits, while counterfactual policy analysis reveals diminishing returns from program expansion.
Read the full abstract ▾
General Economics
Normative boundaries of AI in scientific work: Evidence from PhD researchers
Francesco Angelini and Johan Lyrvall
Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly embedded in scientific work, but researchers may not evaluate its use uniformly across research tasks. This study examines task-specific attitudes towards AI among an international, self-selected sample of 3,785 PhD students in STEM and medical and health sciences who participated in Nature's Graduate Survey 2025. We analyse respondents' comfort with using AI for writing a research article, collecting and analysing data, designing experiments, tracking scientific literature, and summarising it. Latent class analysis identifies four distinct attitudinal profiles. The dominant profile reflects a "division of labour," in which AI is widely accepted for literature-related tasks but resisted in activities closely associated with intellectual contribution, such as writing, data analysis, and experimental design. A "status quo" profile is broadly uncomfortable across tasks, an "all-purpose" profile is broadly comfortable, and an "undecided" profile expresses substantial uncertainty. These patterns suggest that attitudes towards AI in research are organised less around a simple acceptance-rejection divide than around task-specific boundaries, likely concerning delegation, authorship, and responsibility. Because the survey measures comfort rather than legitimacy, the profiles are best interpreted as attitudinal configurations with a normative dimension. The findings highlight the importance of task-specific approaches to AI governance, doctoral training, disclosure, and research evaluation.
Read the full abstract ▾
Theoretical Economics
The Reverse Big Push: Generative AI and Self-Fulfilling Automation
Soumen Banerjee and Jianguo Wang
Generative AI relocates the fixed cost of automation. A model provider pays to train a frontier system, while a downstream firm rents capability by usage; the same firm must carry a continuing payroll to supply a human-augmented service. We study this asymmetry in a local service economy with household budgets and a
market-clearing wage. Human augmentation earns a larger surplus from an additional customer, whereas automation has the lower break-even scale. Payroll supports demand across sectors. Wage adjustment works against this feedback but does not generally undo it: when the wage-income effect dominates the fall in the wage bill per retained worker, production modes are strategic complements. The economy can then possess both a high-demand human-augmented
equilibrium and a low-demand automated
equilibrium. The former is the local first best, even when flexible wages prevent a firm-profit ranking. With forward-looking firms and staggered revision opportunities, the same inherited employment structure can support an automation cascade or an augmentation recovery; the anticipated path of later adopters validates the first movers' choices. Under the regularity and boundary conditions of Frankel and Pauzner, a public aggregate shock selects a unique state-contingent path, while the vanishing-friction limit selects according to risk dominance. A transparent parameterization anchored to professional-services revenue-to-payroll ratios illustrates how high-autonomy uses can enter the coordination region and how wage adjustment compresses that region. Optimal policy combines the adoption wedge created by demand spillovers with a temporary bridge when the low state is locally self-sustaining.
Read the full abstract ▾
General Economics · Cross-listed from cs.SI
Social Network Structure, Wealth, and Wealth Inequality Across Cultures
Eleanor A. Power, Monique Borgerhoff Mulder, Samuel Bowles et al. (+57 more)
Despite theory tying wealth inequality to social structure, empirical evidence has been limited to a few studies based on online social media data. This study uses a very different type of data, expands the global coverage to very different types of societies, and investigates new questions. In particular, we collect data from ~3500 sharing units (households) in 46 communities across the globe, representing considerable human social and cultural diversity. In each, we analyze the relationship between people's material wealth and the structure of social networks: borrowing money, sharing food, working together, socializing, etc. In almost all communities, a sharing unit's material wealth is positively associated with the number of other sharing units it both helps and is helped by. A sharing unit's wealth is also associated with the relative wealth of the sharing units to which it is linked—a form of economic homophily. Notably, communities with greater wealth inequality are also characterized by a network structure in which poorer sharing units are less well connected to wealthier ones. We augment our unique cross-cultural data with other community-level environmental, institutional, and economic attributes, opening new avenues for future research into the co-determination of wealth and social networks.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Eleanor A. Power, Monique Borgerhoff Mulder, Samuel Bowles, Matthew O. Jackson, Jeremy Koster, Daniel Redhead, Thomas Rutter, Sahana Subramanyam, Justin Weltz, Nurul Alam, Sarah Alami, Alexandra Alvergne, Curtis Atkisson, Michele Barnes, Bret Beheim, Christine M. Beitl, Madeline Brown, Mark Caudell, Wendy Chávez-Páez, Komal Chauhan, Joshua Cinner, Siobhán Cully, Augusto Dalla Ragione, Angelina L. DeMarco, Ivan Deschenaux, Federico Fernandez, Juan Pablo Ferreiro, Drew Gerkey, Matthew Gervais, Christopher Golden, Gianluca Grimalda, Werner Hertzog, Paul L. Hooper, Karen Kramer, Geoff Kushnick, Banrida Langstieh, Rodrigo Lazo, Sheina Lew-Levy, Shane Macfarlan, Emmanuel Maliti, Karl J. Mertens, Madalena Monteban, Rafael Morais Chiaravalloti, Daniel Murphy, Kathryn Oths, Alejandro Pérez Velilla, Emily Post, Sean Prall, Cody Ross, Anirudh Sankar, Brooke Scelza, Michael Schnegg, Edmond Seabright, Mary K. Shenk, Kathrine E. Starkweather, Chun-Yi Sum, Bram Tucker, Bapu Vaitla, Vivek Venkataraman, John P. Ziker
Econometrics · Cross-listed from stat.ME
SAUSS: Stochastic Approximation with Unbiased Simulated Scores for Limited Dependent Variable Models
Sokbae Lee, Yuan Liao, Myung Hwan Seo et al. (+1 more)
Multinomial choice models allow flexible substitution patterns but become computationally demanding with many alternatives or observations. With a fixed per-observation simulation budget, simulated maximum likelihood introduces simulation bias, while each optimization step requires a full-sample likelihood evaluation. We propose
Stochastic Approximation with Unbiased Simulated Scores (SAUSS), an averaged
stochastic approximation based on conditionally unbiased mini-batch score estimates. Each iteration uses a fixed mini-batch regardless of sample size. For multinomial probit, accept-reject sampling provides exact conditional draws and unbiased score estimates for any fixed number of accepted draws. Under local conditions, asymptotic theory for the averaged
estimator and the partial-sum process of the SAUSS iterates incorporates mini-batch and simulation variability and supports random-scaling and plug-in inference. In simulations and an application, SAUSS gives comparable results in less than 1% of the computation time of simulated maximum likelihood. SAUSS extends to limited dependent variable models with conditional-expectation score representations and exact conditional sampling.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Sokbae Lee, Yuan Liao, Myung Hwan Seo, Youngki Shin