Logic · Cross-listed from cs.SC
Papers
Fresh from arXiv, typeset properly. Highlighted words trade on the market.
Thursday 10 September
The discovery of the EML operator, sufficient to evaluate the standard explicit purely transcendental elementary functions, has led to considerable interest and discussion across multiple scientific disciplines. However, most authors have focused on the binary EML itself, while numerous similar variants with slightly different properties are now known. This article attempts to close this gap by enumerating and classifying them. We also take this opportunity to clarify common misconceptions related to the EML operator. The principal goal, symbolic regression within an architecture as close as possible to proven neural networks which combine matrix multiplication with a single univariate non-linear activation function, remains beyond reach. Instead, we propose a Möbius layer, with rational functions replacing matrix operations, and showcase the recently discovered activation function eml(x,1/x), which allows exp(x) and ln(x) to be recovered separately, and hence all elementary functions to be evaluated within a rational generalization of the neural network.
Logic · Cross-listed from math.FA
On weak dominance of t-conorms over t-norms
The weak dominance of aggregation operators, particularly between triangular norms (t-norms) and triangular conorms (t-conorms), has attracted considerable attention in aggregation operator theory. While several characterizations have been obtained for Archimedean and continuous cases, a general criterion for continuous t-conorms over continuous t-norms remains to be fully clarified. In this paper, we provide a complete characterization of a continuous t-conorm weakly dominating a continuous t-norm. We first reduce the problem for ordinal sum operators to that for their single Archimedean components, and then express the weak dominance condition entirely in terms of the additive generators of these components. Our approach covers both strict and nilpotent cases uniformly, and recovers the known results for Archimedean operators as a special case.
Read the full abstract
Logic
There is no maximal $K$-degree
The Kolmogorov complexity of a string characterize how complex it is to describe the string. If every prefix of a real $x$ is more complex to describe than every prefix (of the same length) of real $y$, then it is seen as $x$ is more complex to describe than $y$. It is wondered if there is a real $x$ so that no other reals are strictly more complex (to describe) than $x$. The behavior of Kolmogorov complexity functions generated by reals (namely $n\mapsto$ the minimal description length of the real) is quite chaos. Therefore, it is widely believed that there are many reals that are maximally complex to describe. For instance, it is conjectured that all random enough reals have maximal $K$-degree. In this paper, it is shown that there is no real with maximal $K$-degree. Actually, for almost all real $x$, we can uniformly computably find another real whose $K$-degree is strictly above $x$.
Read the full abstract
Wednesday 9 September
Logic
A Note on Lowness for $\Pi^0_1$-Immunity
We show that the only degree which cannot co-enumerate a non-trivial $\Pi^0_1$-immune real is $\emptyset$, resolving a conjecture of the author. The main ingredient is that if a real $A$ has that all $A$-maximal sets are c.e., then $A$ has c.e. degree, which can be proved via a coding mechanism and two classical results of Lachlan.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Non-elementary modal logics, assuming P $\neq$ NP
A modal logic is elementary if it is sound and complete with respect to an elementary class of Kripke frames. We prove that if a finitely axiomatizable modal logic L is elementary, then the validity problem for L, which asks whether a given finite Kripke frame validates L, is in P. This allows us to transfer complexity results in graph theory to the study of elementarity of modal logics. As an application, we construct infinitely many finitely axiomatizable K4-stable logics that are not elementary, assuming P $\neq$ NP. This result provides a conditional negative answer to an open question in [Bezhanishvili et al., 2018] for K4-stable logics.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Well-Defined but Not Predetermined Persistent Mathematical Objects, Embedded Observers, and the Provability of P = N P
We develop a foundational distinction between well-definedness and predetermination. A persistent mathematical or computational object may return a unique answer whenever a query is made and preserve every previously returned answer, while its answers to as-yet unqueried inputs are not represented by one completed, history-independent extension. We call such an object well-defined but non-predetermined. We next formulate an observer-based semantics. All observers inhabit one shared computational world, their interactions modify one common global state, and they have access to one realized history. Under axioms of shared history, historical irreversibility, persistence, and historical indistinguishability, embedded observers cannot establish from the realized history alone whether its compatible extension was predetermined or progressively formed. A persistently evolutionary polynomial time computable oracle supplies a concrete example and yields a deterministic–nondeterministic separation under an explicitly history-sensitive semantics. We then derive a conditional result concerning the provability of \(P=NP\). The conclusion is an observer-relative unprovability theorem, not an unconditional proof of classical \(P\neq NP\).
Read the full abstract
Logic
Simultaneous extensions of states on quantum logics
Suppose that L is a quantum logic (= an orthomodular poset) and A, B are Boolean subalgebras of L. Suppose further that s1(resp. s2) is a state on A (resp. on B). We ask when both s1 and s2 allow for a simultaneous extension over L. Under a natural necessity condition on A, B, s1, s2 we find a sufficient condition for the existence of the extension. This condition is the requirement of an abundance of two-valued states on L. We then show by the Greechie pasting technique that this condition is far from necessary even for state-space-rich logics.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Compact totally separated types
Perhaps surprisingly, there are infinite types that can be exhaustively searched mechanically in finite time. We use ideas from topology to build plenty of them, referring to searchable types as compact types, and we use ordinals to measure their logical complexity. We consider two systems of ordinal notations under which a single notation denotes both a discrete ordinal and a compact one, with an embedding of the former into the latter whose image has empty complement. A boolean valued function decides which points in the image of the embedding are isolated and which are topological limit points. The first system consists of the traditional Brouwer codes and the second is an inductive-recursive universe generalizing them. The discrete ordinals so obtained are trichotomous, and the compact ones have the least element property for complemented subsets, but these two desirable properties cannot be fulfilled simultaneously in a constructive setting. The ordinals obtained from Brouwer codes further enjoy a boolean Leibniz principle, which has the notion of total separatedness as its topological counterpart. This extends previous work from Gödel's system T to intensional Martin-Löf type theory with univalent universes, and is formalized in Agda in the TypeTopology repository.
Read the full abstract
Logic · Cross-listed from math.GR
Finite presentations of metabelian groups: effective enumeration via Laurent relations
For an ordinary finite presentation $P=\langle x_1,\ldots,x_n\mid R\rangle$, put $G(P)=F_n/\langle\langle R\rangle\rangle$. We construct a primitive-recursive predicate $V$ with $G(P)''=1 \Longleftrightarrow \exists c\in\mathbb{N}: V(P,c)=1$. Thus finite presentations of metabelian groups are recursively enumerable, answering Kourovka Problem 17.124. An effective form of the Bieri-Strebel covering construction, using signed Laurent relations and rational separation, gives a family of finitely presented metabelian groups cofinal under epimorphisms. Products of conjugates of defining relators witness these epimorphisms. The construction and enumeration theorem are formalized in Lean 4.
Read the full abstract
Logic · Cross-listed from math.OA
Every $\mathrm{AW}^*$-Algebra is Normal
Using set-theoretic methods, we prove that every $\mathrm{AW}^*$-algebra is normal, resolving a question of Wright that has stood open for 46 years. This was previously known in the case of $\mathrm{AW}^*$-factors, by work of Saitô and Wright. We also show that if there is a model $V$ of $\mathrm{ZFC}$ with an $\mathrm{AW}^*$-algebra that fails to be monotone complete, then in some forcing extension of $V$ there is an $\mathrm{AW}^*$-factor that fails to be monotone complete, implying that any $\mathrm{ZFC}$ proof that all $\mathrm{AW}^*$-factors are monotone complete yields a $\mathrm{ZFC}$ proof that all $\mathrm{AW}^*$-algebras are monotone complete. Both results build on transfer principles for Boolean-valued factor representations originally developed by Ozawa. This work was assisted by the Danus LLM orchestration system.
Read the full abstract
Logic · Cross-listed from math.OA
Lifting for N-independent sets in II1 factors
In a tracial von Neumann algebra M, two subsets X and Y are said to be N-independent if alternating products of length at most N of trace zero words from X and Y have trace zero. We show that two approximately 2N-independent finite tuples can be perturbed, in operator norm, to be exactly N-independent. Consequently, we are able to generalize Theorem 5.1 and Theorem H of Houdayer-Ioana and resolve Problem 31 of Kunnawalkam Elayavalli in the positive.
Read the full abstract
Tuesday 8 September
Logic
Frobenius Galois expansions of substructural logics:Algebraization, Kalman equivalence and positive cone semantics
The main aim of this paper is to introduce a Frobenius–Galois expansion of the substructural logic $\mathbf{FL}_{ew}$ and develop its algebraic and categorical semantics. The resulting logic, denoted by $\mathbf{FL}^{\mathbf{FGC}}_{ew}$, is obtained by adjoining a pair of unary connectives forming a Galois connection and satisfying suitable Frobenius-type compatibility conditions. Firstly, we prove that $\mathbf{FL}^{\mathbf{FGC}}_{ew}$ is algebraizable in the sense of Blok and Pigozzi and identify its equivalent algebraic semantics with the variety of Frobenius-adjoint residuated lattices, establishing the conservativity over $\mathbf{FL}_{ew}$ and relating its finite model property to residual finiteness of finitely generated free algebras. Secondly, for the distributive setting, we lift the Kalman construction to the Frobenius-adjoint algebraic framework. More precisely, we establish a categorical equivalence between Frobenius-adjoint residuated distributive lattices and Frobenius-adjoint $c$-differential residuated distributive lattices with the condition $\mathbf{CK}$. This equivalence yields a positive-cone representation of the former structures and, in turn, a logical counterpart of the categorical correspondence. Finally, for the distributive extension $\mathbf{FL}^{\mathbf{FGC},d}_{ew}$, we prove that derivability, validity over Frobenius-adjoint residuated distributive lattices, and validity over the corresponding positive cones determine the same consequence relation, and further show that this correspondence preserves equational and quasi-equational consequence, conservativity, and finite countermodels. These results provide a unified algebraic, categorical, and logical framework for Frobenius–Galois expansions of substructural logics.
Read the full abstract
Logic · Cross-listed from math.NT
The Archimedean place is a blurred interval at infinity
Classically, the places of $\mathbb{Q}$ are often regarded as a one-point compactification of $\mathrm{Spec}(\mathbb{Z})$, with the real place corresponding to a formal “prime” added at infinity. Re-examining this picture from a topos-theoretic perspective reveals a subtler geometry: while the non-Archimedean places are identified with singletons indexed by the non-zero prime ideals of $\mathbb{Z}$, the Archimedean place is represented by the space of upper reals $\overleftarrow{[0,1]}$, which may be informally thought of as the unit interval equipped with a non-Hausdorff topology. On a technical level, our analysis brings together geometric logic and descent techniques from topos theory, distinguishing standard descent from lax descent toposes both at the level of sheaves and of the geometric theories they classify. More broadly, this paper brings into conversation two parallel distinctions: on the number-theoretic side, between Archimedean and non-Archimedean phenomena, and on the topos-theoretic side, between standard and lax descent. Looked at from a high level, these perspectives begin to converge on a common theme: how should the connected and the disconnected interact?
Read the full abstract
Logic
On a topological duality for Stonean Hilbert algebras
The aim of this paper is to present a topological duality for the algebraic category of Stonean Hilbert algebras and certain morphisms between them, called $\neg$-morphisms. Also, we apply this duality to characterize the Heyting algebra of $\alpha$-ideals of a Stonean Hilbert algebra.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Kontsevich-Zagier conjecture for Hensel-minimal fields with sections
We generalise Yin's motivic integration with section to the Hensel-minimal framework, with and without volume forms, building on Stout and Vermeulen's work on a Hrushovski-Kazhdan style motivic integral for $1$-h-minimal valued fields. In particular, we get a bijective motivic integral \emphà la} Hrushovski-Kazhdan between certain Grothendieck groups of definable sets on the valued field and the coarse Grothendieck groups on $\mathrm{RV}$ in the Denef-Pas language, with angular component. In the second half of the article, we build a Cluckers-Loeser-like framework and show that our constructions indeed give back Cluckers-Loeser motivic integral. Thus Cluckers-Loeser motivic integration derives from an isomorphism of Hrushovski-Kazhdan motivic integration, but in the Denef-Pas language with a section of $\mathrm{RV}$.
Read the full abstract
Logic · Cross-listed from quant-ph
Spectral Sign Implication for Quantum Logic
We study the spectral sign implication for quantum logic, defined by the nonnegative spectral projection of the operator obtained by subtracting the antecedent projection from the consequent projection. The construction agrees with classical material implication on commuting projections and compares arbitrary pairs of projections through the spectral structure of their difference. It satisfies Hardegree's four minimal implicative conditions, his law of contraposition, and a falsity condition. It differs from the standard polynomial implications in that its value need not belong to the ortholattice generated by its arguments. Within a uniform class of Borel constructions for pairs of projections, the operations satisfying entailment, contraposition, and the falsity condition correspond exactly to measurable choices of spectral branch. In the continuous subclass, these three conditions determine the spectral sign implication uniquely. In finite dimensions, the operation is also the largest among the acceptance projections of optimal projective tests for Helstrom discrimination between subspace states with priors proportional to rank. These results connect quantum implication with the operator theory of two projections and binary quantum discrimination.
Read the full abstract
Logic
A Bounded Finite-One Degree Whose One-One Degrees Form Exactly a Dense Linear Order
We construct a set $U\leq_T\emptyset''$ whose bounded finite-one degree, ordered internally by one-one reducibility, consists exactly of a countable dense linear order without endpoints. More precisely, \[ \left( \{[B]_1:B\equiv_{\mathrm{bfo}}U\},\leq_1 \right) \cong (\mathbb Q,\leq). \] This exact realization contrasts with two previous results. In earlier work, a bounded finite-one degree was constructed that contains a copy of $(\mathbb Q,\leq)$, but the same degree also contains an infinite antichain of one-one degrees and, more generally, embedded copies of all countable partial orders; thus the dense chain does not exhaust the degree. In a different direction, $m$-rigidity yields an almost-sure and comeager obstruction: for a measure-$1$ and comeager class of sets, the corresponding bounded finite-one degree contains an infinite antichain of one-one degrees and hence is not linearly ordered. The present construction shows that, despite this typical negative behaviour, exact dense linear order can occur. In particular, it gives an affirmative answer to Open Question~3 of Richter, Stephan, and Zhang. The proof has two main parts. A block homogenization construction produces a noncylindrical set $U$, a weak dyadic tower $(U_e)_{e\in\mathbb N}$, computable reservoirs of both colours, and a base absorption property. An abstract absorption-to-exhaustivity theorem then shows that every member of the bounded finite-one degree of $U$ is one-one equivalent to some finite autojoin $mU_e$, thereby yielding the exhaustive classification above.
Read the full abstract
Monday 7 September
Logic
A non-trivially non-trivial automorphism at an inaccessible cardinal
We show that, relative to the existence of an inaccessible cardinal, it is consistent that for an inaccessible cardinal $\kappa$, there is a non-trivial automorphism of $\mathcal{P}(\kappa)/\mathrm{fin}$ whose restriction to $\mathcal{P}(\beta)/\mathrm{fin}$ is induced by a bijection on $\beta$ for every $\beta<\kappa$. This answers questions posed by Larson–McKenney, Shelah–Steprāns, and Veličković.
Read the full abstract
Logic · Cross-listed from math.GN
A solution of the D-space Problem
Settling a central problem in set-theoretic topology, and many related problems, we prove that there is, consistently, a regular Lindelöf space of cardinality $\aleph_1$ that is not a D-space. The existence of such a space is independent of ZFC; we establish its equivalence to a weak form of the Continuum Hypothesis. The proof of the main theorem is adjustable to produce consistent examples with a variety of stronger properties.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Combinatorics in 1-semi-equational theories
We give direct combinatorial proofs that 1-semi-equational theories satisfy two combinatorial properties that imply the non-interpretability of certain fields. Our main result is that Boolean combinations of 1-semi-equations have almost linear Zarankiewicz bounds, and hence no infinite field is interpretable in a 1-semi-equational theory; this answers a question of Chernikov–Mennen and Chernikov–Starchenko, who had respectively established almost linear Zarankiewicz bounds for Boolean combinations of $(2,1)$-semi-equations and Boolean combinations of weakly normal relations. (This was recently and independently established by Gou, Mirabi, Mittal, Tran, and Yang, using different techniques and producing different bounds.) We also show that $(k,1)$-semi-equations satisfy the $\delta$-strong Erdős–Hajnal property with $\delta=1/6^{k-1}$; this had previously been established by Chernikov–Starchenko for an ineffective constant $\delta>0$.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Failure of the $G_0$-dichotomy for generalized Cantor spaces
Kechris, Solecki and Todorčević's $G_0$-dichotomy characterizes Borel graphs that admit a Borel measurable coloring with countably many colors. We show that the analogue to the $G_0$-dichotomy for generalized Cantor spaces fails at the lowest possible complexity, namely for closed graphs.
Read the full abstract
Logic · Cross-listed from cs.LO
Monadic Second-Order Logic in HOL: Deep and Shallow with Automated Faithfulness (Extended Preprint)
In Isabelle/HOL, we apply the deep-and-shallow embedding methodology of our prior work to monadic second-order logic (MSO). Three embeddings are developed side by side: a deep embedding (an inductive datatype with an explicit satisfaction relation); a maximal-shallow embedding that translates the connectives and quantifiers directly into HOL, carrying the interpretation and both assignments explicitly; and a minimal-shallow embedding – a locale that fixes those parameters, collapsing the formula type to bool. The enabling new ingredient is a two-sorted substitution apparatus – capture-avoiding substitution, renaming, and a substitution lemma per namespace – in which each binder is transparent for the other; faithfulness of all three embeddings is mechanised and largely automated. Our central contribution is a fully mechanised two-sorted downward Loewenheim-Skolem theorem: the minimal embedding recovers deep validity relative to the (countable) assignment ranges, and this range-relative reading is shown to coincide with the general (Henkin-style) reading of MSO, whereas the standard reading validates strictly more formulas, witnessed by comprehension. Both readings are nonetheless recovered from the minimal embedding, differing only in the admitted interpretations: all of them for the general reading, only the elementary substructures of the full model for the standard. We exercise the embeddings on classical MSO landmarks: the Boolean-closure and graph schemata hold under the full second-order domain yet fail in the minimal embedding, making the dichotomy concrete, while reachability and 2-colorability are refuted throughout.
Read the full abstract
Logic · Cross-listed from math.RA
Higher-dimensional generalized quasiorders
It is well known that the polymorphism clone of a quasiorder is determined by its unary part, in the sense that any operation is a polymorphism if it satisfies the condition that all unary functions obtained by fixing some of its variables at constant values are polymorphisms. We show that a clone satisfies an analogous property for a particular fixed arity $d$ if and only if it is determined by a collection of what we call higher-dimensional generalized quasiorders whose dimension is equal to $d$. We define higher-dimensional generalized quasiorders with the appropriate generalizations of reflexivity and transitivity to the higher-dimensional setting, which rely on an explicit analysis of 'rectangular' arity.
Read the full abstract
Logic
A Set-Theoretic Translation of Modal Logic via Forcing
We develop a set-theoretic translation of a normal modal extension $T_m$ of a recursively axiomatizable first-order theory $T$. We first pass to the Henkin expansion of the underlying language by adding witness constants and work with the sentence algebra of this expansion. The translation is constructed using the corresponding Lindenbaum-Tarski algebra, the Stone space of its ultrafilters, and quotient forcing by a $\sigma$-ideal of Borel sets; in particular, the meager ideal yields Cohen forcing and the null ideal yields the random forcing. In a Boolean-valued universe, we interpret the modal operator $\Box$ by membership of the Boolean value of the translated formula in a suitable filter name. We prove that this translation is sound and complete: a modal formula is provable in $T_m$ if and only if its set-theoretic translation is forced in every associated interpretation. We then build Kripke frames and models from generic extensions and show that the forcing interpretation of $\Box$ agrees with quantification over the corresponding accessibility relation. As a consequence, we obtain completeness with respect to the resulting Kripke models.
Read the full abstract
Sunday 6 September
Logic
Inequalities and equalities of means in Constructive Mathematics
We study the inequalities and equalities of means of numbers in constructive mathematics. The parameters of such means are constructive real numbers. We show that it is impossible to have an algorithm that can always decide whether the two means are equal or not. Of course, this problem can always be solved if the parameters are rational numbers.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Tag-system computation using only powers and principal logarithms
I show that one exact step of any tag system can be written as a single fixed expression using only powers and logarithms. A tag state is represented as an integer; evaluating the expression yields the integer encoding of the next configuration, and feeding the answer back into the same expression follows the computation step by step. The discrete part of the update comes from leveraging the wraparound in the principal complex logarithm, which effectively serves the same purpose as floor, mod, or sin in comparable approaches. The iterating expressions use only $x^y$ and $\log_b a$: it turns out that these two binary operations are sufficient, with no need for constants. It follows that reachability below a fixed threshold is undecidable for one fixed expression. As a separate application, the same mechanism represents addition, $2^x$, and remainder with the convention $x\bmod0=x$, and hence every Kalmár elementary function.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Vopěnka's Principle without Choice: Preservation under Symmetric Extensions
We give a detailed proof that every set-sized symmetric extension of a model of $\mathsf{ZF}+\mathsf{VP}$ again satisfies $\mathsf{ZF}+\mathsf{VP}$, where $\mathsf{VP}$ is formulated for arbitrary set-sized languages. For each standard $n\geq 1$, the same preservation theorem holds for $\mathsf{VP}(\Pi_n)$, with set parameters and arbitrary set-sized languages. We also prove that $\mathsf{ZF}+\mathsf{VP}$ and $\mathsf{ZFC}+\mathsf{VP}$ are equiconsistent, and that $\mathsf{ZF}+\mathsf{VP}$ proves the existence of a proper class of Löwenheim-Skolem cardinals. Relative to $\operatorname{Con}(\mathsf{ZF}+\mathsf{VP})$, the axiom $\mathsf{DC}$ is independent of $\mathsf{ZF}+\mathsf{VP}+\neg\mathsf{AC}$. The preservation theorem also yields Feferman-Lévy and full Solovay models satisfying $\mathsf{VP}$. We consider whether every countable model of $\mathsf{ZF}+\mathsf{VP}$ has a class-generic extension satisfying $\mathsf{ZFC}+\mathsf{VP}$.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Preserving the Ultrapower Axiom by Forcing over Nonoverlapping Extender Models
We identify a class of simple yet nontrivial forcing notions that preserve the Ultrapower Axiom (UA) over canonical inner models, reaching the level of a strong cardinal. The forcings we consider are discrete product forcings whose index sets are chosen and spaced according to the structure of the underlying nonoverlapping extender sequence. As an application, we show that UA is consistent with the existence of a strong cardinal $\kappa$ such that $V\neq \text{HOD}_X$ for every $X\in V_\kappa$, answering a question of Goldberg.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Approximation by simple structures
In her graduate thesis, Gwyneth Harrison-Shermoen developed an abstract framework for approximating structures of a given theory, which generalized the notion of smoothly approximable structures. At the time it was unclear how broadly the framework applied due to a lack of examples. In this paper we will show that with slight modification to the framework, several well-understood $\mathrm{NSOP}_1$ theories are in fact approximable by simple structures. We discuss certain structural properties of the limit structure that can be obtained from the approximation and introduce a notion of limit dimension as a candidate for recovering Kim-independence in the limit structure. We also provide some examples of structures that are not approximable by structures of finite Morley rank.
Read the full abstract
Logic
Representing a ring as the endomorphism ring of an abelian group
We investigate Baer's realization problem for almost free abelian groups, focusing on the extent to which rings can be represented as endomorphism rings under strong freeness conditions. Building on earlier work that relied on additional set-theoretic principles such as the diamond or strong black boxes, we develop new methods that significantly weaken these assumptions. The main result is obtained in ZFC (assuming a mild cardinal arithmetic configuration): for a strong limit singular cardinal $\mu$ with $\mu^+ < 2^\mu < 2^{\mu^+}$, and for a wide class of cotorsion-free rings, we construct $\mu^+$-free modules whose endomorphism rings are isomorphic to the given ring. This provides a substantial partial solution to a problem of Göbel and Trlifaj. The key innovation is the integration of $\kappa$-frame constructions with Shelah's Super Black Box, enabling a delicate diagonalization that eliminates nontrivial endomorphisms while preserving high degrees of freeness.