Combinatorics · Cross-listed from cs.AI
Autonomous disproofs of the sum-product conjecture over $\mathbb R$ with GPT-5.5 Pro
Yichen Huang
OpenAI's recent disproof of the Erdős unit distance
conjecture marked a milestone for AI in mathematics. It also inspired another breakthrough: a human disproof of the Erdős–Szemerédi sum-product
conjecture over $\mathbb R$. In this paper, we present a simple
agent built on GPT-5.5 Pro. Using a problem-agnostic, three-stage prompting pipeline – proof-plan proposal, proof construction, and review – the
agent autonomously generated correct proofs that the sum-product
conjecture is false over $\mathbb R$ in 7 of 8 independent trials; in the remaining trial, it identified an unresolved gap in its argument. The seven proofs are diverse: some are close to existing unit-based constructions, while others avoid units by using $L^p$-type regions of algebraic integers. The system used an average of 132.4k
reasoning tokens per trial. We release the code, intermediate outputs, and generated proofs, providing a reproducible, data-contamination-free case study in autonomous proof generation.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
Odd-cycle defects in the Alon-Friedland bound
Mohsen Aliabadi and Elliot Krop
Let \(G\) be a finite simple graph. We study perfect matchings through two complementary viewpoints: reductions to bipartite permanent terms and the directed cycle covers counted by the ordinary adjacency permanent. The main identity is an explicit odd-cycle-indexed form of the classical cycle-cover expansion: it separates \(\perfmat(G)^2\), the even-cycle-cover contribution coming from superposing two perfect matchings, from the contribution of cycle covers containing odd cycles. This gives a nonnegative odd-cycle defect \(\delta_{\mathrm{odd}}(G)\). Combining the identity with the Bregman–Minc inequality yields a structural refinement of the Alon–Friedland degree-sequence bound. We prove product, positivity, and fractional-perfect-matching interpretations for the defect; show that for \(K_{2n}\) the defect asymptotically accounts for almost the entire Bregman–Minc target; and derive from this a derangement identity. We also study near equality in the Alon–Friedland bound: we classify all one-edge perturbations of the extremal graphs, record the uniform obstruction coming from \(K_4\), and formulate a sharp bounded-degree gap problem whose two natural candidate extremal graphs cross between maximum degrees \(9\) and \(10\).
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics · Cross-listed from math.NT
A counterexample to a subadditivity conjecture of Cohen for Sophie Germain cyclic numbers
Josué Alexander Ibarra
An integer $n \ge 1$ is cyclic if $\gcd(n,\varphi(n))=1$ (equivalently, if every group of order $n$ is cyclic), and Sophie Germain cyclic if both $n$ and $2n+1$ are cyclic. Let $C_\sigma(N)$ count the Sophie Germain cyclic integers in $[1,N]$. Cohen conjectured that $C_\sigma$ is subadditive, $C_\sigma(m+n) \le C_\sigma(m)+C_\sigma(n)$ for all $1 \le m \le n$ (his
Conjecture 66), having checked $m,n \le 10^6$ without finding a counterexample. We give one: at $m=31$, $n=3928$, $C_\sigma(3959)=697 > 696 = C_\sigma(31)+C_\sigma(3928)$. The argument is short, and is verified by the Lean 4 kernel.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics · Cross-listed from cs.LG
AlphaZero in Sparsely Rewarded Games: Limits and Auxiliary Supervision
Brent Kong, Tejas Ram and Tony Yue Yu
AlphaZero has demonstrated that a neural-guided Monte Carlo Tree Search can achieve superhuman performance, but strong play does not necessarily imply perfect play. We study this gap in two oracle-evaluable domains with contrasting structure: Connect Four, a solved partisan game with exact game-theoretic values, and Chomp, an impartial game whose optimal play is governed by Grundy-number structure. Under a unified self-play $+$ MCTS pipeline, we compare vanilla AlphaZero, a multi-frame variant (limited to Chomp), and an AlphaZero Auxiliary Loss (AZAL) that adds oracle-derived policy supervision. We find that vanilla AlphaZero achieves strong play across both domains but cannot preserve the exact trajectories required for optimal play: in Connect Four, it fails to maintain the optimal line of play, while in Chomp, it fails to consistently restore the $g=0$ invariant. On rectangular Chomp boards, multi-frame inputs alone do not remove this gap. Nevertheless, AZAL substantially improves oracle consistency across multi-seeded full-game traces and sampled-state evaluations. On Chomp, AZAL reaches perfect full-game oracle consistency on 10x11 and high but not complete consistency on 9x10; on Connect Four, AZAL improves oracle-match rate and delays the first oracle mistake, but does not reach perfect play.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
The Redheffer Matrix Parity Problem
Anthony Hernandez
A solution determining the parity of unit entries in Redheffer
matrices is given. The solution solves the problem by enumerating two disjoint sets from which set membership determines parity. The solution framework uses generating functions.
Combinatorics
Online Komlós converges to mean curvature flow
Nestor Guillen and Vladimir A. Kobzar
We determine the asymptotics of a game inspired by classic vector balancing problems in combinatorial discrepancy theory. In this game, which we call the online Komlós game, two players, Paul and Carol, update the state vector $y$ in $\mathbb{R}^m$, initially placed at $0$. At each round, Paul chooses freely a set of $n$ vectors in the Euclidean unit ball, and Carol chooses, for each such vector, whether to leave it unchanged or reverse its sign. The resulting vectors are all added to $y$, and the game proceeds to a new round. After $T$ rounds, the game ends, and the $\ell_\infty$ norm of the state vector $y$ is determined. Paul's objective throughout the game is to maximize this norm, and Carol's objective is to minimize it. As $T$ gets large, we establish that the leading order term of the value of this game is $\sqrt{T/2\tau}$, where $\tau$ is the extinction time of the unit cube in $\mathbb{R}^m$ under a
curvature-based flow characterized by the values of $m$ and $n$. When $n\geq m-1$, this flow is the mean
curvature flow, and we show that $1/\sqrt{2\tau} =\Theta(\sqrt{\log m})$. Our results build upon the work of Kohn and Serfaty on deterministic games and mean
curvature flow, combined with Banaszczyk's $\ell^2$ analogue of the Beck-Fiala
theorem. As the large $T$ limit of the online Komlós game amounts to a localization of the classic Komlós problem, we hope this work can shed light on this and other vector balancing problems. Our results generalize to the version of the online Komlós game with the final value given by an arbitrary norm in $\mathbb{R}^m$.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
Improved bounds for a discrete John-type theorem
Danila Solunov
Tao and Vu introduced a discrete analogue of John's
theorem in which convex progressions are approximated by generalized arithmetic progressions. In the covering version of this problem, one asks for a small GAP containing all
lattice points of a given origin-symmetric convex body. We prove that every such convex progression in dimension $n$ admits an infinitely proper GAP cover whose size is within a factor $O(n)^{2n}$ of the cardinality of the original set, improving the previously known factor $O(n)^{3n}$. We also show that a loss of order $\Omega(n)^n$ is unavoidable for infinitely proper GAP covers.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics · Cross-listed from math.OC
Polynomial Matrices in Integer Programming With Restricted Subdeterminants
Marcel Celaya, Stefan Kuhlmann and Robert Weismantel
We introduce a framework for tackling questions in discrete optimization associated with parametric constraint
matrices. More precisely, the constraint
matrices have entries that are
polynomials in one variable and all subdeterminants of these
matrices are
polynomials in a given prescribed set $S$. Two key problems arise in this context. The first is the recognition problem: can a
matrix of this form be recognized in
polynomial time? The second is the optimization problem: given an integer program whose constraint
matrix is of this form, can it be solved in
polynomial time? We answer both questions affirmatively for a particular set $S$ consisting of nine linear forms. The
matrices we consider are of themselves independent interest; they arise as
matrix projections of certain bimodular
matrices that admit two distinct unimodular projections.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
A ChatGPT-assisted Triangle Characterization of Affine Permutation Inversion Graphs
Sara C. Billey, Herman Chau and Kevin Liu
Inversion sets of permutations in the affine symmetric group $\widetilde{S}_n$ were studied extensively by Björner and Brenti. One of their methods for encoding an inversion set is through an affine inversion graph, which is a certain weighted graph on vertex set $[n]=\{1,2,\ldots,n\}$. Subsequent work by Papi characterized which graphs arise as affine inversion graphs. In this paper, we provide an alternative characterization in terms of a simple local condition on each triangle in a weighted tournament graph. This new characterization was produced with the assistance of ChatGPT, which suggested several key insights that simplified portions of Papi's original characterization. Consequences of our characterization include efficient
algorithms for recognizing inversion graphs and inversion sets. Furthermore, we give bounds on the weights along directed paths, and we show that standardizing the labels on an induced subgraph results in another inversion graph. We conclude with a new order $O(|R|+n^{3})$
algorithm for testing if a given set $R$ is the inversion set of an affine permutation.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
Endre Boros
In a binary
polynomial optimization problem (BPO, in short) we are maximizing a multilinear
polynomial expression depending on n binary variables. This is a hard optimization class, containing many NP-hard problems, including unconstrained quadratic binary optimization. Several tractable special classes were considered in the literature, including problems with bounded tree-width (Crama, Hansen, Jaumard, 1990), Berge-acyclic problems (Buchheim, Crama, and Heck, 2019), $\beta$-acyclic problems (Del Pia and Di Gregorio, 2022, 2023), limited reach problems (Clausen, Crama, Lusby, Rodríguez, and Ropke, 2024), and $\alpha$-acyclic problems with bounded rank (Del Pia and Khajavirad, 2025). We focus on a general variable elimination scheme for BPO, and develop the unique explicit multi-linear
polynomial form for the equivalent BPO problem obtained after the elimination of a given subset of the variables. The obtained closed form representation of such an equivalent BPO problem allows us to characterize new special classes for which this elimination method, when applied recursively, provides a computationally efficient solution. Our approach is elementary1, algebraic, and provides efficient solution to a wide problem class that properly generalizes all of the above mentioned tractable special cases.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
Upper chromatic number of generalized quadrangles
Gabriela Araujo-Pardo, Julián Fresán, Linda Lesniak et al. (+1 more)
We can regard a generalized quadrangle as a hypergraph in which points and lines are identified with vertices and hyperedges, respectively. A vertex coloring is said to be rainbow on a hyperedge if all vertices contained in that hyperedge are assigned pairwise distinct colors; if no hyperedge is rainbow, the coloring is termed rainbow-free. For a given hypergraph $H$, the maximum integer $k$ for which there exists a rainbow-free $k$-coloring is called the upper chromatic number of $H$, and is denoted by $\overline{\chi}(H)$.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Gabriela Araujo-Pardo, Julián Fresán, Linda Lesniak, Mika Olsen
Combinatorics · Cross-listed from math.GR
Subindices and subfactors of $\mathbb{Z}_n$ and $k$-index stability of finite groups
M.H. Hooshmand
We study subindices, subfactors, and index stability in the cyclic group $\mathbb{Z}_n$. We prove several
theorems that not only confirm a
conjecture and resolve some open problems about index stability of such groups, but also provide basic tools for the characterization of finite $k$-index stable groups. As a consequence, we completely characterize all 2-element index stable subsets of $\mathbb{Z}_n$, obtain an exact closed formula for their density, and determine all $n$ for which every 2-subset is index unstable. Finally, we present some problems and a research project extending the study to 3-subsets and general $k$-subsets.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
The matroid intersection conjecture
Dominic van der Zypen
We prove the matroid intersection
conjecture, due to Nash-Williams \cite{ahaziv}, for infinite matroids: If $M_k = (E, {\mathcal I}_k)$ are matroids for $k \in \{0,1\}$, both having the same base set $E$, then there is $J^* \in {\mathcal I}_0 \cap {\mathcal I}_1$ and disjoint subsets $J_k\subseteq J^*$ for $k\in \{0,1\}$ such that $\text{cl}_{M_0}(J_0) \cup \text{cl}_{M_1}(J_1) = E$.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
Gilbreath's conjecture: a Cramér random model and a deterministic analysis
Zachary Chase, Zach Hunter and Terence Tao
Gilbreath's
conjecture asserts that if one starts with the sequence of
primes and takes successive absolute differences to create a triangular array, then the left diagonal of this array consists entirely of ones after the first row. In this paper, we show that the analogue of this
conjecture for a Cramér random model holds, in which the (normalized)
prime gaps are replaced by independent random variables with
geometric distributions of logarithmic size. We also give some preliminary analysis of the associated continuous probabilistic model for this problem, as well as a deterministic "inverse
theorem" that isolates the specific obstructions to Gilbreath's
conjecture (assuming a Cramér type bound on
prime gaps), namely long blocks of zeroes, or very long shallow $\{0,d\}$-valued blocks for some $d \geq 2$.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics · Cross-listed from math.DS
$K$-spherical horospherical averages on the Nagao quotient: tree combinatorics and exact discrepancy
Sanghoon Kwon
Let $q$ be a
prime power, $F=\mathbb F_q(\!(t^{-1})\!)$, $G=\mathrm{SL}_2(F)$, $\Gamma=\mathrm{SL}_2(\mathbb F_q[t])$, and $K=\mathrm{SL}_2(\mathbb F_q[\![t^{-1}]\!])$, and let $U<G$ be the upper unipotent subgroup. We study right $K$-spherical averages along $U$ on $X=\Gamma\backslash G$. Expanding translates of compact $U$-orbits and compact-open F$\unicode{x00F8}$lner-ball averages become terminal layers of rooted descendant shadows in the Bruhat–Tits tree. In the even sector, we compute the Haar height law and signed finite-scale discrepancy exactly. This yields $K$-spherical equidistribution for compact-orbit translates and, for irrational boundary endpoints, for F$\unicode{x00F8}$lner-ball averages. For a depth-$N$ shadow rooted at height $k$, with cutoff $M=N-k\ge0$, bounded-profile errors are $O_q(q^{-M})$ in the backward state and $O_q(q^{-M/2})$ uniformly for moving roots, while the shadow law eventually agrees exactly with the Haar law on every fixed finite height window. For $|\Phi(2m)|\le Cq^{\alpha m}$, $\alpha<2$, three rate regimes arise, with a linear-in-scale factor at $\alpha=1$ and explicit moving-root dependence. Artin continued-fraction digits eventually encode the cutoff and these rates excursion by excursion through individual digit degrees.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
Twofold universality of large-$N$ melonic random tensors
Carlos I. Perez-Sanchez
We construct a measure that exhibits two aspects of a new type of universality and dramatically simplifies the integration of tensors $T_{a_1,a_2,\ldots,a_D} \in \mathbb{C}$ ($a_1,\ldots,a_D=1,\ldots,N$) at large $N$. In contrast to
matrix integration, in which
matrix traces canonically yield the integrand, tensors need additional information (equivalent to a $D$-coloured graph $B$) to contract their indices and form a tensor trace $B(T)$. We show that, whenever each $B_1,\ldots, B_n$ can be obtained by a recursive construction known as melonicity, then the leading order in $N$ of the integral of $ {B_1}(T) {B_2}(T) \cdots {B_n}(T) $ is independent of the – often intricate – combinatorics of the traces $B_i$, but also, to our surprise, independent of $D$ as far as $D\geq 3$. Instead, at large $N$, these integrals are some functions (indexed by $n$) of the number of vertices $2p_i$ of $B_i$ which we call melonic
polynomials. Melonic traces cumulants with respect to any ('interacting') measure \[ \exp\Big\{-N^{D-1} \sum_{i=1}^m g_i {B_i}(T)\Big\} \mathrm{d}\mu_0(T) \quad (g_1,\ldots,g_m \in \mathbb{R}, \mathrm{d}\mu_0(T) =\text{the tensor Gaussian}) \] with each $B_i$ melonic, can be computed with our universal measure that replaces each $B_i$ by a canonical trace depending only on $p_i$. We prove that any two melonic tensor models are indistinguishable at large-$N$, independently of the number of tensor indices (first universality aspect), and of the fine-grainedness of their interactions (second universality), being a sufficient condition that the couplings (the parameters $g_i$ above) agree and their respective traces are monomials with the same degree in $T$.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
Two-block cycles and chromatic number of Hamiltonian digraphs
Ruilin Zheng, Junying Lu, Xiaolin Wang et al. (+1 more)
Let $k$ and $\ell$ be positive integers. The family $C(k,\ell)$ consists of all digraphs obtained from two internally vertex-disjoint directed paths of lengths at least $k$ and $\ell$, respectively, and identifying their initial vertices and their terminal vertices. Addario-Berry, Havet and Thomassé (JCT-B, 2007) asked whether, for any positive integers $k$ and $\ell$ with $k+\ell \ge 4$, the chromatic number $\chi(D)$ is at most $k+\ell-1$ for every $C(k,\ell)$-free strongly connected digraph $D$. Let $D$ be a $C(k,\ell)$-free
Hamiltonian digraph. Kim, Kim, Ma and Park (JGT, 2018) showed that $\chi(D) \le k+\ell$ and the bound is attained when $k+\ell=5$. In this paper, we prove that $\chi(D) \le k+\ell-1$ for $k+\ell\ge 6$ and this bound is best possible for all $k+\ell\geq 6$, which resolves the problem posed by Addario-Berry, Havet and Thomassé for
Hamiltonian digraphs.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Ruilin Zheng, Junying Lu, Xiaolin Wang, Yaojun Chen
Combinatorics
Perfect Matchings with Prescribed Differences Beyond Hall: The Two-Hole Problem
Aryeh Lev Zabokritskiy
The Balister–Győri–Schelp (BGS)
conjecture asks whether every zero-sum list of $2^{s-1}$ nonzero vectors in $\mathbb{F}_2^s$ is the prescribed-difference profile of a perfect matching. The
conjecture remains open in general, whereas the classical Hall hyperplane case is solved when all prescribed differences cross between two affine copies of a hyperplane. We isolate the smallest mixed case beyond Hall: exactly two prescribed differences are internal. Although only two requests have changed type, the complete Hall permutation is replaced by a prescribed-difference bijection between two punctured copies of the hyperplane, with two unknown deleted vertices on each side. We call this the two-hole problem. We develop a new combinatorial method for prescribed-difference matchings, based on counting and the character structure of the binary vector space. Unlike the known Hall-type methods, which construct a matching through a sequence of local algorithmic choices, our approach proves existence through a global noncancellation phenomenon. This loss of algorithmic structure is compensated by a different advantage: the method can retain global boundary information that local exchanges do not control. As a first application, it gives a new proof of the binary Hall
theorem, and it then yields a complete solution of the two-hole problem with no multiplicity assumption. We also give direct constructive proofs for symmetric even-multiplicity two-hole and four-hole families. More broadly, the new technique provides a framework for studying further subfamilies of the BGS problem by measuring how far their matching structure departs from the Hall case.
Read the full abstract ▾
Combinatorics
Sandpile groups of random bipartite graphs and families of distributions with the same moments
Jason Fulman, Nathan Kaplan, Deepesh Singhal et al. (+1 more)
Recently, there has been significant interest in applying the method of moments developed by Wood and others to study distributions of finite abelian groups that arise in number theory and combinatorics. When the moments do not grow too fast, they determine a unique distribution. We construct large families of distributions that have the same moments. These families include several distributions that arise naturally in the study of sandpile groups of families of random graphs. Wood determined the distribution of Sylow $p$-subgroups of sandpile groups of Erdős–Rényi random graphs. This was extended by Mészáros to sandpile groups of random $d$-regular graphs, who observed an interesting special case when $d$ is even and $p = 2$. We study Sylow $p$-subgroups of sandpile groups of random bipartite graphs and similarly find a special case for $p =2$. Although this distribution differs from that of Mészáros, we show that they have the same moments and fit into our broader construction. To compute the moments of the distributions we study, we apply combinatorial tools from the theory of Hall–Littlewood functions.
Read the full abstract ▾
All authors Jason Fulman, Nathan Kaplan, Deepesh Singhal, S. Ole Warnaar